I am sure this has been done in the past but not since I've been here. Curious on what your favorite 5 NCs are. Narrowing to 5 is not easy IMO :-)

I should preface this before- I have a number of Tats that I have not tried in my humi.

Mine in no particular order:

LFD Airbender
Padron 64 anni lance
Opus X Robusto (don't know the actual name)
Oliva Master Blend 3 torp
Davidoff Special R
[Reply]

Aged Anejo Shark
Tat Noella
Berger and Argenti Quad Maduro
601 Blue
Cain FF

I know I have missed something, but this is it for now.
[Reply]

In no order

My father no.1
Illusione MJ12
San Lotano oval habano
DPG jj
DPG firecracker
[Reply]

Tatuaje TAA
Quesada Oktoberfest
Fuente Short Story Maduro
LP9
Viaje Satori Zen
[Reply]

I am sure it will change when I smoke more cigars out of my humidor....but I will try
Tat noella
Illusione 88
Illusione epernay
Gran habano zulu zulu habano
and padron 1926 maddie 35
[Reply]

Some good cigars listed thus far.

1) Liga Privada Dirty Rat
2) Fuente Anejo 77
3) Tatajue Cojonu '09
4) Liga Privada T52
5) La Aroma De Cuba Mi Amor
[Reply]

Not all are still available but just going quick off the top of my head. Definitely a tough question though.

1 - Tatuaje East Coast
2 - Tatuaje Anarchy
3 - Liga Privada T-52
4 - Tatuaje TAA
5 - Liga Privada Feral Pig

Anyone seeing a pattern? :-)
[Reply]

Heck mine changes almost monthly. So many great cigars out there.
1. Alec Bradley Tempus Maduro
2. Ashton Aged Maduro
3. Fuente Sungrown Double Chateau
4. My Uzi Weighs a Ton
5. Padon 4000 Mad.
As I typed this I thought of several others I want to put in.:-)
[Reply]

Esencia Petite Corona
Illusione Epernay Le Petite
Funete Anejo Shark
Fuente Hemingway Classico
Don Pepin Firecracker
[Reply]

1. T52 Pig
2. LP 9
3. My Father Lance
4. Ashton VSG (Illusion)
5. ESG

Always changing...
Pretty much any aged Opus...:-)
Definitely a hard question though!!
[Reply]

Illusione Holy Lance
Tatuaje Anarchy
Liga Privada No 9
Viaje Holiday
Padron 3000 (or LFD DL it's a toss up)
[Reply]

I'm some what new and haven't tried a whole lot so heres my top five as of now.

Diesel UHC
DPG JJ
5 Vegas "A"
Est. 1844
Brick House

In about that order.
[Reply]

In no particular order

Illusione Holy Lance Candela 2011
Tatuaje Pork Tenderloin
Anejo Shark 2010
Viaje Exclusivo Robusto 2010
Liga Privada Dirty Rat
[Reply]

aged Opus X
PAM 64
Oliva V's
Oliva V Maduro from 2008
VSGs
[Reply]

LP 9 Flying Pig
DPG JJ Maduro
601 Blue
My Father 343
Tat Fausto
[Reply]

not in order

lp9
oliva v
diesel uhc
nub cameroon
601 blue
[Reply]

Dunno. Haven't smoked many higher end NC's (Never had the standard crowd pleasers like Padron anni's/family reserves), but out of the NC's I have had:

Viaje Skull & Bones Mystery
Viaje Skull & Bones Daisy Cutter
Torano Tribute 2008 Torp
Fuente WOAM
Illusione MK
[Reply]

Off the top of my head and in no order...

Oliva Orion
Padron 45th Maduro
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos #2
Casa Fuente Lancero
E.P. Carrillo Dark Ritual
[Reply]

Padron 64 Anni
Padron 26 Anni
Anejo
and other stuff.
[Reply]

Hasn't changed much in the past two years...

#1: Viaje Holiday Blend
#2: 601 Blue
#3: DPG JJ Series Maduro
#4: Liga Privada #9
#5: CAO MX3
[Reply]