Cutter 52 54.74%

Punch 9 9.47%

I use both regularly. 34 35.79%

What do you use the most or does it vary greatly on the type of cigar?

I bought a punch recently and have only used it once. I think I like the tighter draw more with the punch that with a standard guillotine cutter. But I'm a noob so I don't know what I'm talking about.

I know some cigars, like the Drew Estate Java with a rectangular shape would be very difficult to get a clean cut.
[Reply]

I rarely use a punch. Not that I dont like the way it draws, I'm just more comfortable with a cutter.
[Reply]

Cutter for me, but I have never used a punch. I have tried a V cutter before and liked it.
[Reply]

Cutter all day for me. :-) I used to use a punch when I first started, but the tar build up was a big turn-off.
[Reply]

I use a cutter 99.9% of the time. I'd say I use a punch maybe 2-3 times a year.
[Reply]

cut cut cut
[Reply]

I always use them, except when I don't.

Of course... this only happens if I am by myself or with somebody.


:-)
[Reply]

this
[Reply]

Cutter, unless I forget it at home. My lighter has a punch as a back up.
[Reply]

Punch unless i smoke a torpedo or a lancero
[Reply]

I have been using a cutter more lately, But still love the punch!
[Reply]

Cutter at home and punch for travel; smoke more at home so the cutter gets used more often.
:-)
[Reply]

If your cutter is not giving you a clean cut, you need a better (sharper) cutter. Square press, triangle press, factory press, box press cigars, etc. all cut the same as a round cigar.
[Reply]

I use a cutter about 95% of the time. The exceptions are large ring gauge cigars that seem to be underfilled slightly.
[Reply]

I use a punch mostly because I don't have a good cutter yet. I plan to pick-up a Palio soon. I use a punch on almost everything except torps.
Punch works great unless what Mac said happens.
[Reply]

I love the way a punched cigar feels vs a cut, and I haven't really experienced the tar build up that others around here have. That's just personal preference though, I can't really say specifically what I like about it, it's just feel.
[Reply]

I cut 99% of the time. I have a Palio but I have a cheap punch, so you see why i cut more.
[Reply]

I prefer the draw from a cut, but I don't have a decent cutter yet, so I only use it on torpedos. I can't get a clean cut on other shapes. I asked for a xi3 for Christmas :-)
[Reply]

I use a cutter. I tried a punch before and I just wasn't used to the feel of the cigar in my mouth.
[Reply]

Have a Xikar XV, X8 and a 009. Almost always use the XV.
[Reply]