So I was gonna ask, if you were stranded on an Island what box would you have to accompny you? I then realized this was too hard of a question. So the majic number is now 3 with the same question!

1. Oliva Serie O Robusto
2. Murcielago Belicoso
3. Illusione MK

This is a tough list but I think this would be it. How about you guys?
[Reply]

1. 1994
2. 1492
3. Partagas Dunhill #777
[Reply]

:-)
[Reply]

1. Cohiba Siglo VI
2. Montecristo #2
3. Cohiba Esplendidos
[Reply]

1. 1994
2. 1492
3. Davidoff #1
[Reply]

I'm a fairly simple guy:

1. BBF
2. Siglo VI
3. Montecristo millenium Robusto's :-)
[Reply]

3X '08 Monte #2s

I am a simple guy as well!!
[Reply]

:-)
[Reply]

Go with the MK's :-)
[Reply]

I didn't even put CC's into thought with this one. I fail.
[Reply]

Carton of Camel Lights x3
[Reply]

I just threw up in my mouth a little bit:-)
[Reply]

1. CAO MX3
2. 601 Blue Maduro
3. Viaje 2009 Holiday Blend
[Reply]

CoLa
Some rare Dunhill (I hear Estupendos are the best so why not)
Some rare Davidoff (probably the No. 1 Lancero)

Hell if I'm stranded and they are free.... Perfect opportunity to try some good vintage $hit that costs tons of $$$$$.
[Reply]

:-)
[Reply]

1. Hemingway Maduro Classic
2. Padron 64 Anny Maduros Exclusivos
3. LP #9(no preference on size)
[Reply]

:-)

I keed I keed. Right now I still have so much to discover I cannot make this decision.
[Reply]

I'm in the same situation. I'm too new to this to decide on a top 3 favorite.
[Reply]

You should make it the top three that you've ever tried. Too easy to pick the ultra rares.
[Reply]

The top three that I have had the pleasure of smoking:

1. Rocky Patel Vintage 1992
2. 5 Vagas Series A
3. Rocky Patel Decade

Please be kind
[Reply]