Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
All Cigar Discussion>Anyone want to talk me down from the ledge?
forgop 11:52 AM 10-18-2010
Anyone ever go through that phase where you have that one box or two of cigars that you probably know in the back of your mind you know you should keep, but you can think of something else to do with that money? There's no replacing them either. In my case, it's a box of Oliva MB1 torpedos and a box of MB2 robustos. I'm toying with the idea knowing that there's no way in hell they'll ever be replaced, but in the long run, they're just cigars and I can get something I'm just as likely to enjoy much cheaper to replace them. Does that make sense?
[Reply]
357 12:00 PM 10-18-2010
Normally I'd try and talk you down, but if funding was in place I'd give you a big push and buy those MB off you.
[Reply]
shilala 12:00 PM 10-18-2010
Yup, makes sense.
If you're not smoking them, sell them. Especially if you'll enjoy what you're gonna buy.
Add to that, you're liable to make someone VERY happy who is is actually going to smoke them. That's reward enough, right?
[Reply]
Addiction 12:00 PM 10-18-2010
Happens all the time.

No I'm not talking you down.

Instead remember this: there is always some new, never to be had thing that pops up. if you had enough of the MBs to let em go then let em go and good riddence. I'm currently moving things out to support a house remodel to accomadate my mother in law so I know how that works.
[Reply]
Subvet642 12:02 PM 10-18-2010
Sell one and keep the other? :-)
[Reply]
Patrick B 12:04 PM 10-18-2010
sell half of each. Plenty of money to buy new stuff and then some people that are dying for these get to try them.
[Reply]
NCRadioMan 12:08 PM 10-18-2010
Did somebody say MB 1's? :-)

5'ers? :-)


Yeah, I think you should get rid of a few. :-)
[Reply]
forgop 12:52 PM 10-18-2010
For some reason, I feel like I'm trying to justify getting a box of Padron 1926 40th anniversary and a box of 1926 80th anniversary cigars. This pretty well gets me on my way I think.
[Reply]
Louistogies 12:58 PM 10-18-2010
I'll take a 5er. :-)
[Reply]
G G 01:03 PM 10-18-2010
Makes sense to me.:-)
[Reply]
forgop 01:04 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by Louistogies:
I'll take a 5er. :-)
I haven't even given a price yet, although I did sell a box of MB1 robustos a couple of months ago for $250 in a matter of minutes of them being listed here.

I checked the box and I have 18/20. I would include 2 MB1 churchills as "replacements" should I go forward. I think I would most likely only sell as an entire box though, but if there was more interest in 5ers, I would consider breaking them up. The box is quite a nice piece as well and those have generally brought $20-30 each I believe in the past.
[Reply]
wayner123 01:17 PM 10-18-2010
Just a FYI. They are re-releasing the MB series. So while yours may be OR, and have some age on them, they "can" be replaced :-)
[Reply]
357 01:18 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by forgop:
I haven't even given a price yet, although I did sell a box of MB1 robustos a couple of months ago for $250 in a matter of minutes of them being listed here.

I checked the box and I have 18/20. I would include 2 MB1 churchills as "replacements" should I go forward. I think I would most likely only sell as an entire box though, but if there was more interest in 5ers, I would consider breaking them up. The box is quite a nice piece as well and those have generally brought $20-30 each I believe in the past.
I might be interested in a 5er depending on price.
[Reply]
forgop 01:20 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by wayner123:
Just a FYI. They are re-releasing the MB series. So while yours may be OR, and have some age on them, they "can" be replaced :-)
This has been said for 2-3 years now at least, so I'll believe they're coming back out when I see it. I know they have more-it's just a matter of if/when.
[Reply]
wayner123 01:21 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by forgop:
This has been said for 2-3 years now at least, so I'll believe they're coming back out when I see it. I know they have more-it's just a matter of if/when.
My source was Jose himself.
[Reply]
forgop 01:23 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by wayner123:
My source was Jose himself.
I had the exact same conversation with him as well a couple of years ago. Like I said, it's been discussed about it "happening any time now", but this has been said quite some time ago.
[Reply]
Brooks W 06:21 PM 10-18-2010
They say a lot of things.

As for replacing, they won't be doing the tatoo on the cigar like they did with the MB1 and MB2, so....

;0

~brooks
[Reply]
Louistogies 10:04 PM 10-18-2010
Originally Posted by forgop:
I haven't even given a price yet, although I did sell a box of MB1 robustos a couple of months ago for $250 in a matter of minutes of them being listed here.

I checked the box and I have 18/20. I would include 2 MB1 churchills as "replacements" should I go forward. I think I would most likely only sell as an entire box though, but if there was more interest in 5ers, I would consider breaking them up. The box is quite a nice piece as well and those have generally brought $20-30 each I believe in the past.
I can't even see the F/S section yet.
[Reply]
Patrick B 12:09 AM 10-19-2010
Keep posting, Lou! I forget the requirements but you can't be far off...
[Reply]
RevSmoke 05:58 AM 10-19-2010
They're cigars, they were made to be smoked.

If they were something that continued to rise in vaolue, then maybe. However, if you need the $$ right now, then these could help you raise the capital you need.
[Reply]
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
Up