Looking for suggestions. Which maduro stick would you recommend? I want that rich, chocolatey, slightly sweet taste, earthy and incense-like but not terribly spicy...But not really mild either...

So far lotta close-but-no-cigars. Oliveros XL for men, Onyx reserve, Fuente chateu maduro, perdomo lot 23... None of them really covering the above hoped for effects.
[Reply]

Oliva V :-)
[Reply]

I was going to say the lot 23 or the Chateau Fuente... Maybe you should try a Rocky Patel Sun Grown. I love them
[Reply]

Never had a maduro?
Start out w/ the 5 Vegas A. Let it rest in the humi for a couple of months before trying it though.
I hated the first maduro stick that I had (can't remember what it was)
Let it rest for a while to mellow out. You can't go wrong w/ a good maduro.
Camacho SLR maduro is great, but expect a powerhouse.
Edge Maduro is the same.
[Reply]

Any Padron maduro should fit the bill.
[Reply]

:-) Nice recommendation, Justin. PAM 64 Prinicpe or a 64 of any type.
[Reply]

Oliva Serie G Maduro is a score
and so is Sancho Panza Souble Maduro Quixote!! :-)
[Reply]

All the Padrons.

The Londres Maduro is a favorite short smoke.
[Reply]

I really liked the Nestor Reserve Maduro. With a little age they were great. Also priced right. Sent a ton of them to the troops and they loved them.
[Reply]

Padron 1926 maduro. You may also like an Ashton Aged Maduro. Both great maduro cigars. :-)
[Reply]

The Padron 1926 #35 maduro is exactly what you are looking for! :-)
[Reply]

try the Oliva Serie G Maduro. i did and ended up buying a box:-)
[Reply]

:-) Those were the exact two cigars I was going to suggest.
[Reply]

EO Brands 601 BP Blue Label Maduro robusto...... great smoke.
[Reply]

Fuente 858 Maduro is one of favorites and it won't break your pocket book.
[Reply]

6000 Padron Maduro
Taboo Maduro
Oliva G maduro
Sancho Panza Double Maduro

Any of these are pretty good...
[Reply]

Smart man.

I have had a few with like a year on them very tasty.

MMMMmmmm....
[Reply]

Yes sir! Also the Pepin JJ Maduro and Torano '59 Black Label. I recently had a Kristoff Maduro that was quite tasty as well.
[Reply]

Camacho 11/18 Triple Maduro is high on my list when I'm reaching for a maduro.
[Reply]

Padron 1926 ANY!:-)

I have a box of #9s in the mail! MAN, I can't wait, it's been way too long.
[Reply]