I keep a regular list, so I don't go crazy.
It looks like this:
El Cobre Torpedos
El Originals Tor Maduros
Avo Maduro #9's
Litto Gomez Chisels or Lusitanos
Blue Band Oliva O's Ovations and Oasis's
Old Henry Maduro Toros
Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte Pamplonas
Padilla Habano Torpedoes
Padilla Artisans or Burberry's
Padilla Oscuro '68 Salamones (if they ever really materialize)
Tampa Sweetheart Maduros
Cuaba Divinos

What's your "gotta get" list look like?
Just wanted to see if anyone else was worse off than me.
Now it's not to say that I don't have any of these cigars, cause I don't think I'm out of any but the Old Henry Maduros, but I like to make a priority list so I don't buy stuff before I get the stuff I really want.
It doesn't work at all, but I like to make believe it helps. :-)
Do any of you other guys or girls keep a list?
[Reply]

Padrons
Perdomo Lot 23
tat whites
more Padrons
[Reply]

If I was in a different situation I would probably keep a list. Your list looks just fine Scott.
[Reply]

I keep a list as well...here is my current one:

Illusione ECCJ
Funete Anejo #55
Ocean Club Rock Patel
Kristoff Maduro
Illusione 4/2G
La Flor Dominicana El Jocko Maduro
La Flor Dominicana Reserva Especial Figurados
Fonseca Maduro
[Reply]

Oliva V figurado
La Aroma de Cuba Especial Edition #5
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero Chisel
Diamond Crown Maximus robusto
H. Upmann No 2
Illusione CG:4

That should be good for awhile.

Those Cuaba Divinos are great BTW.
[Reply]

One of everything I haven't tried...in a nutshell
[Reply]

No list for me. I am pretty much done with NC's although I still pick up an occasional box. Recently picked up a box of Augusto Reyes Nativo Lanceros at 25% of retail. I also have no CC list, mostly I buy what catches my eye and is priced well. But I am willing to try just about anything because you never know what is coming around the corner. Recently tried the 2009 Tat Conjonu, the best Tat I have had and fantastic for something so fresh. :-)
[Reply]

Gee Scott, the first thing that popped into my mind when I first saw this thread was "A Porche 911 SC":-) but then I floated back down to earth...

Probably a bundle of each:

Reserva Miraflor Robustos
Taboo LR Havana Robustos

[Reply]

Padilla Artisans or Burberry's...

They just had a 5-pack deal on these in CI and I missed them. Not sure how
well they smoke, but I've been looking for neat give aways for the birth of my son next month and these would have been perfect.
[Reply]

My gotta get list is pretty simple really. It's things I haven't tried but hear they are very good, or cheapies I haven't got around to buying yet.

San Cristobal
Illusiones
Tatuaje (especially Pork Chop)
Rocky Patel Double Maduro
CAO Criollo
Nica Libre
Anything Indian Tabac
VigilantE Maduro
[Reply]

My list is pretty much any Pepin I have yet to try... otherwise it's mostly Cuban. :-)
[Reply]

Great question. I've been loading the new Mobile Stogie app, and there is a section for a "wish list." I guess it is to help with shopping if you bust out your iphone in the B&M humidor. Mine is blank, at the moment.

Honestly, I'm pretty good on the NC front, for now. There are a few that are intriguing that I don't see too often.
Padillas -- I've had one Miami, but that's it
Devil's Weed -- never seen it in a store
Pinar del Rio

My CC experience is so limited, that anything is a treat.

I'll have to revisit this.
[Reply]

I have never smoked, nor even seen a cuban cigar...so I would have to say cuban cigars are on my gotta get list.
[Reply]

Tat Frank
Cabaguan
a shark
a pork chop
[Reply]

Powermatic PM2000, 5HP 1Ph Table Saw w/ 30" Accu-Fence System & Rout-R-Lift
Festool Kapex KS 120 Sliding Dual Compound Miter Saw
Lifetime supply of router bits

Oh wait, you were talking cigars :-)

I have been very blessed and tried many good and bad cigars.

I use to have a list but now I just smoke what I got :-)

Chas
[Reply]

Laid.
[Reply]

Any RE that I do not have.(That's lots of 'em!)
[Reply]

Not too many on my list, I keep it short to match the bank account:

Party Presidentes
Boli Gold Medals
Padron 64
RP Sumatra
[Reply]

I have a list of things I still want to try and a list of things I just love and want to get a few for in my humi. both too long to mention here though :-)
[Reply]

Cohiba SigloVI
Monte #2
Davidoff CC (any)
God of Fire
More Padron 80ths
[Reply]