Pipe 1 0 0%

Pipe 2 5 16.13%

Pipe 3 7 22.58%

Pipe 4 13 41.94%

Pipe 5 7 22.58%

SMOOTH 15 48.39%

RUSTICATED 14 45.16%

Medium 18 58.06%

Large 10 32.26%

Ok, here are 5 pipes that are the best examples I could find on the website of what people said they wanted. I am going to have you all vote for the shape you would like the best (we're not voting on the exact pipe). Also, I will have an option for smooth or rusticated, please choose one (so JM knows how many of each).

I counted 15 defintely and 6-7 maybes on the other thread, based on this, I want to set an initial limit of 20 pipes. I would rather him need to pick up 1 or 2 extra later, than for him to have 3-4 leftover pipes that he can't sell because it has our "stamp" on it. feel me?

Please vote (select all that apply) on ONE pipe, and ONE finish. (pipes are 1-5 from left to right)

Also, I will include a choice for size of the pipe, please choose medium or large. again, there will be variability, but it'll be a good indicator of size for your pipe.
[Reply]

You know I'm in Tim. Thanks for all the work getting this set up.
[Reply]

I voted for pipe4/rusticated/medium
[Reply]

:-)
[Reply]

I'm still in! I voted for a pipe 4, Smooth, large but medium will do just fine.
[Reply]

Oh yeah, post up any suggestions for our club signature

CA09, CAPF09, etc.
[Reply]

I like CA/09 OR CA2009
I think that "CA09" will look too much like "CAO" with a nine when carved in so it must be separate some how.
[Reply]

I agree, CA/09 is fine.
If not too long, Asylum 09 would be perfect, IMO.
[Reply]

Pipe 4/Smooth/medium, although I also kind of like pipe #2

CA/09 is also cool, but I too like the idea of Asylum 2009 or 09 :-)
[Reply]

Pipe #4, smooth, medium for me:-)
[Reply]

Pipe #4, Smooth, Larger preferably but I'm ok with a medium. Thanks for setting this up.
[Reply]

I like Pipe #2/Smooth/Large. I say on whatever pipe we get we get the rim of it rusticated. That way you don't have to worry about burning the top.

Asylum 09 or CA2009
[Reply]

Since Boswell dates the pipe when he carves it, maybe just Asylum for the club ingraving? I don't know, just throwing that out there.
[Reply]

this was my thought as well (even though I initially put 09 in my suggestions)

it will be dated with his signature, then we could have asylum, and the individual's initials
[Reply]

cool deal, guys. makes me wish i liked pipe tobacco better :-)
[Reply]

Something to think about as well, this will be the first edition of the Clup Pipe. Should that be reflected in the signature?

WWhermit
:-):
[Reply]

Something like this...
____________________________
------J.M. Boswell 09--------
First Edition Asylum Club Pipe
-----Individual's Initials------
____________________________

That will be along the bottom of the shank.
[Reply]

I like that, but this will be hand scribed on each pipe, I don't know that all of that will fit legibly

it'll say J.M. Boswell xx-xx-09 for sure, as it does on all of his pipes

the rest would need to be a word or two at most I imagine
[Reply]

Looks good but if it needs to be shortened, maybe:

J.M. Boswell 09
F.E. Asylum C.P.
Initials
[Reply]

I would like to get in if there is room I went 4 / rusticated / medum
Mike
[Reply]