Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
Island (The other ones) Reviews>el may whore emerald
Legend 10:53 PM 02-18-2009
Legend is on a roll tonight. I'm on my 6th IPA and 4th cigar of the night. So I went with a yard gar. There I go giving away the rating prematurely.

Honestly I avoided this cigar after trying the el may whore espresso. A true dog rocket and one of very few sticks I pitched without finishing multiple times as I gave it a couple chances. Then just have the rest away to someone I didn't particularly like. (just kidding. I threw 3 away). First I call it el may whore because CI is fooling no one. Its their private label and they pimp it like nothing else. Even their other private label (which is not nearly as bad) 5 Vegas.

This one however is not as bad as the espresso. Its a decent yard gar. However more expensive than. The other el cheapo sticks I got recently.

It is made fairly well. While it is a bit loose and fast burning. The draw is always good (a characteristic it shares with 5 Vegas) the flavor is medium bodied and is unremarkable (like most yard gars) and a bit bitter.

I was sure it would be a dog rocket but it surprised me pleasantly and is worthy of a 2 legend rating. I would take my cremosas or the oro's I got cheaper first.

Legend is a bit tipsy and wants to shout out some love to the botl. Big love. Send legend a smoke if you want a review. (shameless plug for free smokes)

Good night.
[Reply]
68TriShield 05:55 AM 02-19-2009
Thanks for the warning :-)
[Reply]
Starscream 06:38 AM 02-19-2009
I enjoy the Esspresso more than I do the Emerald. And both of them beat a cremosa or oro cubano hands down anyday. For me, I believe that the Espresso is a decent yardgar.
[Reply]
BlackIrish 07:01 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by andysutherland:
I enjoy the Esspresso more than I do the Emerald. And both of them beat a cremosa or oro cubano hands down anyday. For me, I believe that the Espresso is a decent yardgar.
:-) Although I kind of like the shaggy foot on the emerald
[Reply]
s15driftking 07:14 AM 02-19-2009
As andy said, the espresso is a great "drunk cigar".

You can even taste it after 3 cigars, haha
[Reply]
14holestogie 07:31 AM 02-19-2009
CI has many more worse than the Emerald. Decent, in my book. :-)
[Reply]
Scottw 08:39 AM 02-19-2009
I love your reviews bud!
[Reply]
mrreindeer 09:23 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by Scottw:
I love your reviews bud!
:-) Absolutely, thanks Shawn & damn good seein' ya!
[Reply]
G G 09:43 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by 14holestogie:
CI has many more worse than the Emerald. Decent, in my book. :-)
:-)
[Reply]
Ratters 09:49 AM 02-19-2009
Yep, I find the Emerald to be a perfectly decent bargain smoke. :-)
[Reply]
borndead1 09:50 AM 02-19-2009
Man, I love the Emeralds. I think they have a very unique flavor.
[Reply]
elderboy02 09:59 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by Ratters:
Yep, I find the Emerald to be a perfectly decent bargain smoke. :-)
+1. I love the Emeralds for the price
[Reply]
s15driftking 10:04 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by elderboy02:
+1. I love the Emeralds for the price
Never cared to try the emerald... but i would pay 4 bucks for an EM espresso. maybe 4.50.
[Reply]
Patron 10:12 AM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by andysutherland:
I enjoy the Esspresso more than I do the Emerald. And both of them beat a cremosa or oro cubano hands down anyday. For me, I believe that the Espresso is a decent yardgar.
I'm with Andy........I like the Espresso, especially with coffee in the morning...don't much care for the Emerald.
[Reply]
Legend 11:37 AM 02-19-2009
Maybe I need to give the espresso another shot. Basically I got a 5 pack. Tried one and pitched it prior to halfway. Which is saying a lot. Hell I can smoke oro cubano and cremosas. Let them sit for a few months and tried another. Pitched it after about an inch and a half. Then round filed the rest. So maybe I'll give one another shot. But I'm not likely to pay for it. Some botl (hint hint) will send me one or two along with some others. :-P
[Reply]
Lucky_Hippo 02:53 PM 02-19-2009
I kind of like the esspresso every once in awhile, but I'm not a huge fan of the emerald. Once you get past the shaggy foot and about an inch or so into the wrapper it makes for an okay smoke, but the first 15 minutes is just tobacco without a remarkable flavor IMHO. I admit, I do like the looks of the shaggy foot, cedar sleeve, and pigtail cap. It makes for a really nice presentation.


:-)
[Reply]
Starscream 03:43 PM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by Lucky_Hippo:
I kind of like the esspresso every once in awhile, but I'm not a huge fan of the emerald. Once you get past the shaggy foot and about an inch or so into the wrapper it makes for an okay smoke, but the first 15 minutes is just tobacco without a remarkable flavor IMHO. I admit, I do like the looks of the shaggy foot, cedar sleeve, and pigtail cap. It makes for a really nice presentation.
:-)

My thoughts EXACTLY on the Emerald.
[Reply]
Ratters 09:01 PM 02-19-2009
Originally Posted by Legend:
Maybe I need to give the espresso another shot. Basically I got a 5 pack. Tried one and pitched it prior to halfway. Which is saying a lot. Hell I can smoke oro cubano and cremosas. Let them sit for a few months and tried another. Pitched it after about an inch and a half. Then round filed the rest. So maybe I'll give one another shot. But I'm not likely to pay for it. Some botl (hint hint) will send me one or two along with some others. :-P
The Espresso is horrid till it gets about six months on it to mellow out the harshness. PM me your addy and I'll send you a fiver next week. :-)

One of the things I like about the Emerald is that flavor change when you hit the wrapper. Shows how much flavor a wrapper imparts.
[Reply]
borndead1 07:47 AM 02-20-2009
Originally Posted by Ratters:
The Espresso is horrid till it gets about six months on it to mellow out the harshness.
One of the things I like about the Emerald is that flavor change when you hit the wrapper. Shows how much flavor a wrapper imparts.

In 100% agreement on both statements.
[Reply]
Legend 08:54 AM 02-20-2009
Originally Posted by Ratters:
The Espresso is horrid till it gets about six months on it to mellow out the harshness. PM me your addy and I'll send you a fiver next week. :-)

One of the things I like about the Emerald is that flavor change when you hit the wrapper. Shows how much flavor a wrapper imparts.
That's love yo.

Pms
[Reply]
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
Up