I got my Stinky and love it!
[Reply]

Another vote for Stinky... I got mine as a raffle prize a few years back in support of huricane relief... Great cause and a Great ashtray.
[Reply]

Stinky for sure.
[Reply]

Stinky is offering up a GB if we can get enough interest... :-)
[Reply]

Got the stinky for when I have friends over but that ashtray Volt posted is what I've been looking for for the man fort, thanks for posting the link
[Reply]

I'd be down for 1.
[Reply]

I have 2 of them and they're great.
[Reply]

I would be in for 1 or 2
[Reply]

I will be working on a GB... :-)
[Reply]

I've got an Upmann too & really like it.

Image

I'd be up for the Stinky GB if I didn't already have 2 trays. Oh well!
[Reply]

I've got that same Upmann ashtray... Nice looking piece. :-)
[Reply]

My favorite is my Oliva ashtray. It looks little in this pic but it's really big. They go super cheap on cbid and sometimes come with cigars...
Image
I have this one, too...
Image
I like it but I don't really use it. Everyone else does though. :-)

I don't want to sound contrary, but I've never desired a stinky even though everyone loves them. I bet it'd be nice to have a couple at a herf, though.
I think it's cause I'm a clean ashtray freak. I like to keep them clean because I enjoy making a mess out of them. All my ashtrays sit outside and I'm afraid a stinky would rust up pretty bad, too.
Any of you guys keep your stinky outside and do they rust?
I could sure use one for all the cigarette hogheads that come around here (not that they'll put their butts in it anyways, but the "wow factor" might entice them.)
[Reply]

Stinky!

But if you seek something unique or unusual I suggest you check out your local thrift shops. You can often find nice vintage ashtrays at a decent price.
[Reply]

Stinky.

I used to love my Tatuaje ashtray, but my stinky quickly replaced it.
[Reply]

Me personally I prefer the CAO Cubist. Saw it once in person and kick my self for not purchasing it. Now it can't be found anywhere.
[Reply]

Id be on on a Stinky or 2 if the price is right. :-)
[Reply]

I have an Oliva that I really like. I got it as part of an Oliva sampler on cigar.com
[Reply]

i'm in for a stinky
[Reply]

I just got off the phone with Stinky and the GB will be off the ground shortly! :-)
[Reply]

Just thought of another idea.....
I picked up a real nice crystal cigar ashtray at a local thrift shop a while back, for like $5.00.....
[Reply]