Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
View Poll Results: Which one?
Box 40 42.55%
Bundle 5 5.32%
Fiver 39 41.49%
Single 10 10.64%
Voters: 94. You may not vote on this poll
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
All Cigar Discussion>Box, Bundle, Fiver or Single?
Martin 06:34 PM 10-21-2008
I usually buy 3's, thats how many boxes fit in one box :-)
[Reply]
REALMCCOY 06:34 PM 10-21-2008
I buy singles for now when I see something that I like or would like to try. Still testing the water. I'll buy a couple boxes come tax return time when I am really sure what suits my taste. I also really enjoy trying new cigars all the time if they share similar profiles of my preferences.
[Reply]
Starchild 06:41 PM 10-21-2008
I started with a few fivers and some samplers. Lately it's been a couple of singles and fivers here and there, trying to narrow down what I want to stock my humi with. I'm on the hunt for aforadable tasty smokes that I can justify a box purchase. If the 5'er price is comparable to to the box price, or if the box is too expensive, I'll stick with the fivers.

I started off heavy on the devil site, but lately it's too much trouble to get a good deal and I just order from CI with free shipping :-)
[Reply]
ucla695 06:49 PM 10-21-2008
I like to sample singles when buying cigars I've never tried before. If I like them, I'll pull the trigger on a 5er for stuff that I want to smoke sooner or a box for sticks that I want to lay down for a while.
[Reply]
av8tor152d 06:51 PM 10-21-2008
I almost always go for a box too afraid that if I like them I won't have anymore. And if I do like what ever it is I buy I want to be able to share :-)
[Reply]
Beer Doctor 06:53 PM 10-21-2008
Lately I've been buying 5ers to try. If I really like the first 3 of my 5er I'll put it on my box wish list. Sometimes it goes slower (i.e. Buy single and like it then buy 5er then buy box). I prefer to have a box if I like it. Although I just filled up my cooler so not much room left:-)
[Reply]
dunng 06:59 PM 10-21-2008
5er is good to get going and then I hit the boxes... :-)
[Reply]
acruce 09:04 PM 10-21-2008
Depends if I am purchasing something I know I like I go with a box. If I am trying something new I go 5ver
[Reply]
cigarmonkel 12:51 AM 10-22-2008
I used to buy a lot of samplers, singles and 5ers. But now that i am a lot more picky then i used to be i'm buying a lot more boxes... :-)
[Reply]
Mystophales 01:47 AM 10-22-2008
Well since doing a header down the dark side it's boxes all the way....to the detriment of my bank account. Thank god for overtime....:-)
[Reply]
livwire68 02:07 AM 10-22-2008
Box or bundle if online, at the B&M singles.
[Reply]
ScottishSmoker 03:50 AM 10-22-2008
I buy almost everything in Singles, mainly because the B&M I go to the most often stashes a few of my favorite boxes away knowing that I will kill the box single handedly...
Last Month
1) Illusione ~4/2g~
2) Cubao #1
3) Tatuaje Reserva SW
Scary enough, this month is looking exactly the same thus far, with one addition...I did buy a box...I found a box of Padron Natural Ambassadors sitting on the upper shelf in the old 25 count box configuration...the cellos are YELLOW!!! AND DAMNED TASTY! (the cigars, not the cellos)
[Reply]
icantbejon 03:55 AM 10-22-2008
Like most, I assume anyway, I started with samplers to find out what I like. I still buy samplers, but they are getting fewer and further between. I've started leaning toward boxes, because buying singles gets pricey. Once I'm home again, I'm sure that will change. It's easier to nickel and dime my collection together without drawing the wrath of my wif.
[Reply]
rsamos 04:22 AM 10-22-2008
I've bought a couple boxes, but I still get most my stock through fivers.
[Reply]
troutbreath 04:38 AM 10-22-2008
Start with a fiver, due to the value proposition over a single. But if it's good, I'll pick up a box -- even more value, plus a cool box.
[Reply]
silentjon 04:44 AM 10-22-2008
If I am trying something new, I usually buy a fiver. Also I have no more room for boxes.
[Reply]
gnukfu 09:33 AM 10-22-2008
I'm a box man ...having said that my next two purchases are a fiver and a three-er.
[Reply]
tsolomon 10:11 AM 10-22-2008
Fivers first, then some boxes, and now several singles before buying more. I first started buying fivers and sometimes I liked them and sometimes I didn't. Then I started buying boxes usually after smoking a cigar that someone had gifted to me. I had a coolerdor and had to fill it, but then my tastes would change and I still had half a box left. I now try to get singles at the B&M and to smoke at least 2-3 before buying more of them. I really like boxes because they protect the cigars, singles and fivers are just loose in the humidors.
[Reply]
kayaker 10:19 AM 10-22-2008
I'm still learning what I like, so 5ers offer up enough sticks of one type to give them an honest try, and maybe even have a stick or two left to trade or share.

However, once I find some that I really like, a box purchase would be the next step.
[Reply]
cigars_n_scotch 10:22 AM 10-22-2008
Originally Posted by petewho:
I say depends on the price. With increase in price comes a decrease in the number I can buy at one time.

Right now I do singles of new stuff, fivers of ones I like, and I've only bought one bundle which was to share. I've yet to take the box plunge.

My next purchase is a cooler, so then the boxes will start.

I am officially done with samplers, I think...
Pete took the words right out of my mouth. I am the same way. I'm on the lookout now for a vino, but with the 28 bottle model being discontinued it's going to be hard. I checked a local target and they didn't even have Vino, they had Haier and something else.
[Reply]
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
Up