Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
Island (The other ones) Reviews>The Obsidian
maninblack 02:44 PM 07-02-2011
Mac and I split a box of these this week so I thought I'd light one up and see how good they really are. These are pretty new smokes with an imposing black band that covers pretty much the whole cigar. The size is a robusto, although at 5.5x54, its pretty big for a robusto. They come in boxes of 20 and run about 60 a box. I paired it with a coke. The wrapper is a habano and it had minimal veins and the foot had a good spicy smell. Good oily sheen to the wrapper also.

Image
The first third had some good spice to it, but not overpowering like I thought it would be. Not really a pepper spice, alot mellower than that. It stayed this way until the second third where it picked up some woody notes along with the spice. This is definitely not a full bodied, ass kicking smoke by any means but its an enjoyable one. Can't really complain for the price point. The woodsy taste stayed until the nub which was appealing. I was happy with the cigar when I was finished. Not very complex, but had the flavors I expected and produced a ton of white billowing smoke. I would give it an 8 out of 10. Maybe come age might help. Was hoping it was more full bodied but hey they all can't be ass kickers.
[Reply]
kelmac07 02:57 PM 07-02-2011
Nice review Kevin. Looking forwarding to enjoying these. :-) :-)
[Reply]
Dunkel 03:08 PM 07-02-2011
I'm going to have to look for a few on C bid. Thanks for the review Kevin.
[Reply]
Drez 03:27 PM 07-02-2011
Nice review Kevin I was looking at these also. Might try and snag a 5er to try.

Also I can use the band to wall paper my new apt :-)
[Reply]
longknocker 03:47 PM 07-02-2011
Who Makes These Kevin? Nice Review!:-)
[Reply]
kelmac07 04:11 PM 07-02-2011
Originally Posted by longknocker:
Who Makes These Kevin? Nice Review!:-)
I believe its Pinar Del Rio.
[Reply]
maninblack 04:23 PM 07-02-2011
What Mac said.
[Reply]
longknocker 04:27 PM 07-02-2011
Originally Posted by kelmac07:
I believe its Pinar Del Rio.
Originally Posted by maninblack:
What Mac said.
Thanks!:-):-)
[Reply]
kickerb 08:30 PM 07-02-2011
nice review, i'll have to give this one a try one day!
[Reply]
Duke50 03:02 PM 07-03-2011
Actually just saw this in cigar.com mag, may have to sample
[Reply]
Tyler 03:10 PM 07-03-2011
Looks like a interesting stick! I will have to pick one up if I see it.
[Reply]
Sherlockholms 03:13 PM 07-03-2011
Great review Kevin, I was curious about how these smoked.
[Reply]
darkninja67 07:19 AM 07-06-2011
Thanks for the review. Will keep and eye out for them
[Reply]
ihocky2 01:49 PM 07-16-2011
I tried one of these earlier this week and pretty much agree exactly on the flavors and the strength. I had one in the 4.5" x 60. I expected it to be stronger, but I would probably only put it as a medium body.

A few additions I noticed are that it was moderately firm, but still a hair soft. I used a punch to cut it because of the larger ring gauge, and it drew really nicely. Burned really even and even letting it sit for up to 5 minutes at one point I never had to relight. About a 45 minute smoke or so, maybe a little longer, in that size. I got about a 1-1/2" ash, but I was tender with it to get it that far, at the 1" point I could see it getting a little fragile. Lots of white smoke, a nice light gray ash.

I will have to try 1 or 2 more before I decide if these earn a place in my collection.
[Reply]
SteelCityBoy 02:18 PM 10-08-2011
Good review and assessment Kevin! Smoked my first one just last night and must agree that it was a good smoke, expecially for the price! Very mellow smoke, not much kick to it. Wasn't very complex either as you stated. For me it stayed pretty consistent flavor wise throughout the entire smoke.

This could easily be an everday smoke for the price...
[Reply]
Blak Smyth 03:14 PM 10-08-2011
Originally Posted by SteelCityBoy:
Good review and assessment Kevin! Smoked my first one just last night and must agree that it was a good smoke, expecially for the price! Very mellow smoke, not much kick to it. Wasn't very complex either as you stated. For me it stayed pretty consistent flavor wise throughout the entire smoke.

This could easily be an everday smoke for the price...
Makes sense you would like it as you are a Pinar Del Rio fan!

Thanks for the review. I thought these would have been full bodied goods to know.
[Reply]
Remo 03:17 PM 10-08-2011
Good review Kev. Thanks
[Reply]
N2 GOLD 03:18 PM 10-08-2011
Thnaks for the good review... :-)
[Reply]
arambo3 07:53 PM 10-08-2011
Good to hear, I just got some off of C-bid. Thanks
[Reply]
WittyUserName 08:33 PM 10-08-2011
Thanks for the review!! Looks like I have to add a couple of these to the list.
[Reply]
Page 1 of 2
1 2 >
Up