I realize they are not premium sticks but if you could just choose one, which one?
[Reply]

None. To me, I haven't had one I liked. I have tried a few more than once.. Same thing.

Cask Strength started off good for me.. Then turned into crap like the rest. I have a Classic and Cask Strength still in the cooler.
[Reply]

The "A" series :-)
[Reply]

Well thanks, that helped me a lot. :-)
[Reply]

:-) The "AAA" is a close 2nd.
[Reply]

Classic and Gold are both nice change of pace for me, had a cask strength as well and liked it.

Generally however I prefer full bodied cigars.
[Reply]

A & Triple A and Gold Maduro for me :-)
[Reply]

I liked the original Cask Strength blend and the Miami was't too bad
[Reply]

If I had to choose one...hands down the AAA.
[Reply]

It has been so long since I had one I can’t recall. I have like 2 boxes including the 2008 anniversary prolly 3-4 years old by now.
[Reply]

I like the Classic torpedo and the Miami. Triple AAA is pretty decent as well.
[Reply]

Cask Strength for me was good.
[Reply]

The Relic by a wide stretch. The AAA comes in second here...
[Reply]

Triple A or Miami depends on my mood.
[Reply]

Tried most. Only two remain in my rotation:
-Cask Strength II
-A in the PC size -- great smoke - much different than any other size A

Triple A not bad, but just didn't do a lot for me
[Reply]

Wow.....

The only "good" one I have had is the "A". I'm yet to have the 3A. The relic is one of the most horriable smokes to date. I put one in my moochador today and it still reels of a green cigar.
[Reply]

My favorite of that line is the Miami series. The Series A is also pretty good :-)
[Reply]

Depends what I'm in the mood for. The one that had the largest impact on me (i.e. I remembered it) was the AAA
[Reply]

+1 on the Miami. Pepin had a hand in that one IIRC.
[Reply]

AAA or the 5 Vega Gold Maduro
[Reply]