Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Wine, Beer, and Spirits>New Year's Champagne/Wine advice
smokeyscotch 11:27 AM 12-28-2009
If this has been asked, I am sorry. I have a special date for New Year's Eve. A girl I've been seeing and I are going to eat a nice dinner, watch some fire works and go to a nice spot. We have decided to save our first kiss till the clock strikes Midnight. What Champagne would you recommend? Or, would you go with one of the Sparkling Wines? I know...I know.. I'm a mushy sumbeotch. Just want to have a nice drink for the occasion as I am ignorant in what might taste good.

Thanks for any help! :-)
[Reply]
Scottw 11:32 AM 12-28-2009
1: What Champagnes have you had that you did like?
2: Are you sure you like Champagne if you haven't had it?
3: How much you want to spend?
4: How long have you been seeing her?
[Reply]
smokeyscotch 05:17 PM 12-28-2009
Originally Posted by Scottw:
1: What Champagnes have you had that you did like?
2: Are you sure you like Champagne if you haven't had it?
3: How much you want to spend?
4: How long have you been seeing her?


1. Haven't had that many. I did have Bollinger and Perrier Jouet as gifts. Liked both. No way I could spend that much.

2. I like Champagne, but wouldn't be opposed to something else. We won't drink the whole bottle probably at one time. Thought about some of the miniatures, but didn't know anything about them. Should probably go to the State Store instead of Wally World.:-)

3. Not a lot. I just want something that tastes good. But, don't want to break out anything really cheap either. I'd say no mre than $40.

4. A week.
[Reply]
ChicagoWhiteSox 05:42 PM 12-28-2009
http://tv.winelibrary.com/2008/12/19...w-episode-598/

This video should help you a lot.
[Reply]
smokeyscotch 06:39 PM 12-28-2009
Originally Posted by ChicagoWhiteSox:
http://tv.winelibrary.com/2008/12/19...w-episode-598/

This video should help you a lot.
Thanks, my friend! :-)
[Reply]
colimo 11:58 PM 12-28-2009
myself i would prefer a good wine over champagne...but if you must go with champagne, at your price point i would go with a moet white star...decent but not extravagant
[Reply]
mmblz 07:46 AM 12-29-2009
Inexpensive but very good:
Saint Hilaire Blanc de Blancs
Should be $12-15
If you won't drink it all at once make sure you have a rubber stopper
[Reply]
krevo 09:37 AM 12-29-2009
For middle of the road, but yet actual "champagne" I usually go for Veuve Cliquot. It can be easily had from 35-50 dollars and is excellent. Same for Piper Heidsieck.

I don't really care for it, but it's usually a special occasion type of item we keep around the house. My fiance absolutely loves it though :-)
[Reply]
mosesbotbol 12:53 PM 12-29-2009
For "Champagne", go for Kirkland/Costco Champagne at around $32. Lot's of non-Champagne Sparkling wines that are good from Roderer Estate, Schaumburg Blanc de Blanc, there a lot good "Cremant" wines from France at that price too.
[Reply]
The Poet 04:00 PM 12-29-2009
If you are not sure she likes champagne, you might consider getting a demi-sec or a rose instead of a brut. They are a bit harder to find unless you go to a decent shop, but they are softer than the bruts, and thus more "drinkable" for the novice.


If you just want to pop a cork, spend 5 bucks on Andre. It may taste like Alka-Seltzer, but boy will it blow off! BOOM!!!
[Reply]
TheRiddick 05:10 PM 12-29-2009
For an incredible QPR buy a bottle of Etoile Rose (2002 is the current release), should be in the $35 range and handily beats most French Rose sparklers.

Also look for Chandon Blanc de Noirs, best deal out there and can be had for $13-14, this is an excellent bottle as well.
[Reply]
gpugliese 06:00 PM 12-29-2009
Originally Posted by TheRiddick:
For an incredible QPR buy a bottle of Etoile Rose (2002 is the current release), should be in the $35 range and handily beats most French Rose sparklers.

Also look for Chandon Blanc de Noirs, best deal out there and can be had for $13-14, this is an excellent bottle as well.
I like Chandon's Blanc de Blanc but didn't like their Blanc de Noirs. Another good cheap Rose/Blanc de Noirs is the Gloria Ferrer Blanc de Noirs, sub $20.

If you really want to impress her, the Billecart Salmon Rose NV is absolutely stellar, but runs about $100. Billecart's Brut Reserve NV can be had for $40-50 and is also excellent.
[Reply]
rlmedic 06:16 PM 12-29-2009
I would do yellow lable Veuve Cliquot for around $35 Its good has a little name appell that I am sure your looking for. Another Idea would to go with a prosecco...its Italian champagne. One I would recomend would be the La Marca Prosecco its around $12 and one of the top 100 wines of 2008 from wine spectator. Good luck!
[Reply]
smokeyscotch 06:14 PM 12-30-2009
Thank you all for the loads of info. I will let you know what I get, as well as how it goes.
Looking forward to and wishing you all a Happy New Year!
[Reply]
SmokeyJoe 10:45 PM 12-30-2009
Originally Posted by colimo:
...but if you must go with champagne, at your price point i would go with a moet white star...decent but not extravagant
My in-laws are Champagne connoisseurs. They drink quite a bit in the $100 to $200 range regularly. However, my FIL is a fan of this particular Champagne, FWIW.

Hope all goes well, Tim! :-)
[Reply]
smokeyscotch 05:16 PM 01-07-2010
Originally Posted by SmokeyJoe:
My in-laws are Champagne connoisseurs. They drink quite a bit in the $100 to $200 range regularly. However, my FIL is a fan of this particular Champagne, FWIW.

Hope all goes well, Tim! :-)
All went good. Got some New Years sugar. However, I think she mught be stalker material. :-)
[Reply]
SmokeyJoe 08:16 PM 01-07-2010
Originally Posted by smokeyscotch:
All went good. Got some New Years sugar. However, I think she mught be stalker material. :-)
Does she look like Glenn Close? Is she paying waaaaay too much attention to your bunny?

If she says, "I wont be IGNORED," head for the hills! :-)
[Reply]
Up