Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Reserva Miraflora Toro
Whee 07:25 PM 10-21-2008
This is version 2.0 of Illinoishoosier's Review Corner. My first review here will be a Reserva Miraflora from GDW Cigars. Andy is a member here and also over at CS. Through PM's, he asked if I would review his cigars and I said sure, why not!

This review was different from other reviews because I smoked the cigar while chatting with Andy, via AOL. Very interesting to share the cigar and review it play by play, so to speak.

Link to info:
http://gdwcigar-products.blogspot.com/

PM AndresMadera GDW for sales info here at the Asylum.

So, without further ado....

Reserva Miraflora Toro
5x54
Nicaraguan Puro cigar

Waiting for death...
Image
Pre lite aroma is sweet and earthy. This cigar has a nice, dark brown, smooth wrapper with small veins. Cap has small defect, but it clip right off, so no worries. Very firm and solid. The initial taste before lighting is molasses, with just a little pepper.

Cigar clipped evenly, very little cast off with the Palio and it lit easily. The draw is firm, but not too tight. The iniial flavor is holding that sweet molasses flavor. Putting out a nice amount of smoke, which, those of you who read my reviews, is a big plus. Burn has started a little uneven, but we'll see how it corrects.

4 minutes in...
Image
Draw is just right and I am getting loads of creamy smoke. Flavor is unchanged.

At 10 minutes, the flavor is very smooth and has picked up some leather. Not in your face flavor. The burn is still a little uneven, but nothing to touch up, yet.

20 minutes...
Image
The flavor has smoothed out to a nice leather and spice taste. Great smoke and draw. the burn has evened out. The ash is a nice light gray
and tight. Very nice smoke so far.

The next 20 minutes the cigar does not change much at all. The flavor, burn and draw are all consistent. Although billed as a full-bodied cigar, it is very subtle at this point.

Look at my ash!! Unfortunately, it dropped a few minutes later. Held for 44 minutes.
Image
50 minutes in and the stick is recovering nicely after the ash drop. Picking up some coffee flavor under the leather. A very pleasant, floral aroma is coming off the stick.

Half an hour later, we are still enjoying the stick. the burn has started to go crooked and it has definitely slowed down a bit. Getting what i can only describe as a "toasty" flavor coming through.
Image
At 90 minutes, the ash is getting a little flaky and I touched up the burn. The flavor, however, is still very nice at this point. Normally, this is where I pitch the stick because it gets harsh, but this one hasn't.

Here, we died, at 99 minuutes!!
Image
I ignored it and it went out on it's own.
Picked up a nice easy nic buzz about halfway through and never got "out of control". The flavors were subtle and consistent all the way through. I would consider this a "medium-full" cigar.

Overall, very nice stick. Andy was great to deal with and it was fun to get his impressions as I was smoking. My pallete was picking up the flavors at pretty much the points where I should.

I give this stick....
4 illinoishoosiers out of 5.

(I know, you;re disappointed no pics in the ratings.)
[Reply]
elderboy02 08:49 PM 10-21-2008
Thanks for the review! I might have to pick up some of these!
[Reply]
ChicagoWhiteSox 09:08 PM 10-21-2008
wow nice review, im gonna have to get me some of these:-)
[Reply]
kiokicigars 03:32 PM 10-22-2008
I have to add my comments here. I smoked it this morning in the car and the aroma unlike a lot of other sticks was just wonderful. Great flavor, but not over powerful at all. The cigar burned great all the way through...super construction and cannot wait to smoke another. Reminded me on the lines of a padron.
[Reply]
AndyMadera 08:13 PM 10-23-2008
Hey Illinoishoosier!

Thank you for the great review. I really enjoyed being able to hear your responses first hand and getting the play-by-play pictures. I would really like to do it again with you or anyone else interested in giving me a live review. I expect other reviews are going to start popping up and you set the bar with a great review!

Andy
[Reply]
elderboy02 05:10 AM 10-24-2008
Originally Posted by AndresMadera GDW:
Hey Illinoishoosier!

Thank you for the great review. I really enjoyed being able to hear your responses first hand and getting the play-by-play pictures. I would really like to do it again with you or anyone else interested in giving me a live review. I expect other reviews are going to start popping up and you set the bar with a great review!

Andy
I just picked up a sampler from Keoki. I can't wait to fire one of these puppies up. They look good and sound good.
[Reply]
MarkinAZ 10:50 PM 10-24-2008
Thanks for a detailed review IH:-)

[Reply]
TOB9595 03:03 PM 11-04-2008
nice review of a stick that I'm hearing more of...

Hmmm, I'll look for a sampler pack of different size
Tom
[Reply]
Up