Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
All Cigar Discussion>Favorite maduro overall?
DaBear 09:03 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by boom:
Padron 64
Hemi maddie
Cabiguan guano rx
Are you me?

Swap out an LP 9 for the Cabiguan and thats my top three right there
[Reply]
MurphysLaw 09:07 AM 04-29-2012
PAM 64 for me, especially the principe and coronas :-)
[Reply]
shilala 09:13 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by MurphysLaw:
PAM 64 for me, especially the principe and coronas :-)
The Principes are incredible, no doubt. I like the Monarca better when there's time, they develop more and I get a lot more of that "incredibly good" last inch that's in a principe. I probably smoke more principes than monarcas, but I'd rather have a monarca. :-)
[Reply]
DaBear 09:25 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by shilala:
The Principes are incredible, no doubt. I like the Monarca better when there's time, they develop more and I get a lot more of that "incredibly good" last inch that's in a principe. I probably smoke more principes than monarcas, but I'd rather have a monarca. :-)
Exactly my feelings. Love the Monarcas, especially since you get a bit more wrapper flavor in em.
[Reply]
MurphysLaw 09:35 AM 04-29-2012
Don't think I've ever had a monarca, guess I need to snag a couple soon.
[Reply]
shilala 09:45 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by MurphysLaw:
Don't think I've ever had a monarca, guess I need to snag a couple soon.
Same ring as the Principe, just longer, Brian. I think one is 4 1/2" and one is 6 1/2".
[Reply]
DaBear 10:17 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by shilala:
Same ring as the Principe, just longer, Brian. I think one is 4 1/2" and one is 6 1/2".
I stand corrected, I think I was thinking of the Exclusivos, not the principes.
[Reply]
shilala 10:34 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by DaBear:
I stand corrected, I think I was thinking of the Exclusivos, not the principes.
Ya still get more wrapper flavor from the monarca, it's longer and builds up more, right? :-)
[Reply]
DaBear 10:56 AM 04-29-2012
Originally Posted by shilala:
Ya still get more wrapper flavor from the monarca, it's longer and builds up more, right? :-)
True, but I just consider that getting more cigar, since its the same RG, just longer, I tend to find it progresses roughly the same just the stages last longer.

And all this talk is reminding me I have a 64 Natural Imperial sittin in the travel humi. Now I'm startin to jones for it. :-)
[Reply]
kuzi16 11:14 AM 04-29-2012
im torn between the Camacho triple maduro or the Davidoff Maduro. <br> i think ill go with the Davidoff though. it has a bit more refined flavor and i find it a touch more approachable.


...save for the price.
[Reply]
dave 09:10 AM 04-30-2012
Oliva V 08
Tat Black PL
T-52 Toro or Torp

To me it has settled out to be more about wrappers than individual cigars:
CT > Nic (with occasional exception) > PA Broadleaf > everything else > San Andres

I know I'm in a small minority, but there are VERY few San Andres-wrapped maduro that I've ever enjoyed.
[Reply]
RobR1205 09:22 AM 04-30-2012
Believe it or not...an old 1998 CAO Maduro Corona (red label). It had aged to perfection. AWESOME!

Other than that, I'm also a fan of the La Aurora Preferidos Maduro
[Reply]
IlmProcess 09:35 AM 04-30-2012
Originally Posted by RobR1205:
Believe it or not...an old 1998 CAO Maduro Corona (red label). It had aged to perfection. AWESOME!
How are these out of the store (not 14 years old haha)
[Reply]
Ciro 09:49 AM 04-30-2012
Camacho Triple Maduro, still one of my favorites.
[Reply]
RobR1205 10:34 AM 04-30-2012
Originally Posted by IlmProcess:
How are these out of the store (not 14 years old haha)
Ah my apologies, upon closer inspection of the band which I saved, it seems not to be the original 1998. It is however, the vintage CAO maduro from several years ago, not the newer CAO L'Anniversaire Maduro remake. I wish I had more details, but it was gifted! :-)
[Reply]
abanytime 11:23 AM 04-30-2012
Great choices here! I've got some great ideas for future selections.

Thanks, and by all means keep them coming...
[Reply]
Islayphile 11:31 AM 04-30-2012
601
Padron 80th
[Reply]
IlmProcess 11:31 AM 04-30-2012
Originally Posted by RobR1205:
Ah my apologies, upon closer inspection of the band which I saved, it seems not to be the original 1998. It is however, the vintage CAO maduro from several years ago, not the newer CAO L'Anniversaire Maduro remake. I wish I had more details, but it was gifted! :-)
No problem, thanks for the info and glad you enjoyed your smoke!
[Reply]
ironchefscott 05:39 PM 04-30-2012
Padron 1964 exclusivo
Liga privada #9
and I belive le bijou 1922 is a maddy too right?
[Reply]
DaBear 06:30 PM 04-30-2012
Originally Posted by IlmProcess:
How are these out of the store (not 14 years old haha)
I personally love the L'Anniversaire Maddies. Great smokes at a good price. Nice and chocolatey. :-) Makes me hanker for one, but we don't carry them at work unfortunately.
[Reply]
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
Up