I have heard really good things about your avatar. I would love to give that a try. :-)
[Reply]

Just finished an El Mejor Espresso that pretty much fit the description above for me.
[Reply]

:-) They're all good, start with the X000 and then the 64 and 26.
[Reply]

Padron 1926 Maduro gets another vote from me.
[Reply]

:-) The Torano '59 has a lot of chocolate flavor. It's one of my favorites. The JJ Maduro, Vegas 'A' and the SP Double Maduro are great every day maddies as well. :-)
[Reply]

:-) Also Saint Louis Rey Maduro, Camacho SLR Maduro and CAO Maduro.
[Reply]

Here are some of my favorites:

JML 1902 Churchill
El Rey Del Mundo Robusto Larga
Sancho Panza Double Maduro Quixote
La Veja Habana The Early Years Silencio
Bucanero el Capitan Maduro Peg Leg
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature Maduro
Arturo Fuente Anejo No. 77 Shark
Padrón 1964 Anniversary Principe Maduro
[Reply]

I personally enjoy the Oliva Serie O maduro and Padron's are great as well. I have a Oliva G maduro which I have not tried. All are great values as well IMO.
[Reply]

If your looking for a great maduro, try the Cohiba Secretos 5 Maduro... Of but if you mean you wanted to find something from this side of the waters, I dont think you can really find a better robusto than the Padron 2000 Maduro.
[Reply]

Any Oliva or Padron Maduros! :-)
[Reply]

:-)
[Reply]

Camacho Triple Maduro should get you where you want to be :-)
[Reply]

CAO MX2
[Reply]

As well on mine too! JJ Maddies are good, also the Oliva G already mentioned on here.
[Reply]

One vote for Pepin JJ Maduro
[Reply]

I just finished a Kristoff Maduro Torpedo and it was really enjoyable. Smoked one about 11 months ago and it was only so-so but after almost a year's rest it has really come into it own.
[Reply]

[quote=Jimmy Robusto;23768]Looking for suggestions. Which maduro stick would you recommend? I want that rich, chocolaty, slightly sweet taste, earthy and incense-like but not terribly spicy...But not really mild either...

Well as far as I'm concerned the flavors your looking for are definitely in the Padron 1964 series. At the risk of sounding like a rich jerk (which I'm not)...the 1926 80th anniversary was an awesome delivery system of these flavors but good luck finding them and even better luck finding a friend who will treat you to one.
I also think that the CAO maduro will have what you're looking for and it's a little cheaper than the 1964 series. I'm surprised you said the Onyx Reserve didn't give you what you were hoping for.
[Reply]

Kristoff maduro & maduro ligero's were awesome smokes. Try em if you havn't yet
[Reply]

The only one I smoke that I will buy by the box WOAM. And with age they are fantastic.:-)
[Reply]

My two current favorites are the 601 Blue Maduro and the DPG Serie JJ maduro. I love them both. The Perdomo Reserve maddy is good too.
[Reply]