Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 2 of 5
< 12 34 > Last »
All Cigar Discussion>Are these fake??
Drkns 11:11 AM 04-06-2012
Measurements are alright that's why I was confused. I started smoking cigars with cohiba Double corona LE 2003 and they were awesome at the time. I am just surprised seeing it today. Cigars are hard to come by in my country and as usual there are fakes and real ones as well.
[Reply]
RichieBklyn 11:22 AM 04-06-2012
Originally Posted by Drkns:
OK they cigars are fake but how about these??????
Image
Image
Does it really mattter.....
[Reply]
Islayphile 11:23 AM 04-06-2012
Originally Posted by RichieBklyn:
Does it really mattter.....
If you can touch them they are real
[Reply]
the jiggler 11:26 AM 04-06-2012
Image

Pretty sure these are real.
[Reply]
357 11:52 AM 04-06-2012
:-)
[Reply]
bobarian 12:13 PM 04-06-2012
Apparently, now the mod's need to ban banter from discussion threads. :-)

I
[Reply]
awsmith4 12:21 PM 04-06-2012
Originally Posted by bobarian:
It is extremely difficult to determine authenticity from pictures or by price. As Albert said, check the exact measurements on the site referenced.

From the pictures there is nothing that screams "fake" :-)
I agree Bob, nothing in the OP's pictures look fake. I thought maybe the wrapper seemed too dark but not compared to the picture at CCW

http://www.cubancigarwebsite.com/ima...cigar_orig.jpg

The price would make me think twice but I guess you just need to smoke them and find out
[Reply]
Adriftpanda 12:29 PM 04-06-2012
I think I payed close to $50 a piece for mine, like Bob mention, nothing screams out fake to me. It could be the lighting but at first glance, I thought the cigar was way too dark.
[Reply]
Drkns 01:32 PM 04-06-2012
I bought one 2003 DC limited edition, 2004 limited edition, maduro 5 and partagas limited edition 2008. The place I bought is not habanos but then habanos does not exist in Turkey.

The sizes are exact match, the bands are all look and feel true. I am either extremely lucky or fakes gotten a long way and become indistinguishable, in this latter case, I am worried. The darker color is due to my hands shadow. The original DC limiteds that I smoked back in 2003 were rather greenish brown in color as far as I remember but they were not aged and rather dry. Oh well I will know when I smoke em.

Thanks all.
[Reply]
bobarian 01:34 PM 04-06-2012
When you are done smoking, cut open what's left. It is very easy to tell short from long filler. :-)
[Reply]
Drkns 01:48 PM 04-06-2012
Bobarian can you give an example?
[Reply]
bobarian 02:03 PM 04-06-2012
Here is a decent video showing short filler. Basically, short filler is a bunch of bits and long filler are whole leaves.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj83W...eature=related
[Reply]
Poronico 02:29 PM 04-06-2012
EAT IT SUCKERS!
Image
[Reply]
AlohaStyle 02:33 PM 04-06-2012
Just comparing the Edicion Limitada band on the 03, the top row of gold dots are definitely different than the band on CubanCigarWebsite. The correct band on Trevor's site has an even amount of black space above and below the gold dots. Your band is much different. Your band's gold dots also look pretty blurred together and not as detailed as the correct band.

Judging by price, where you bought it and that band, I say fake. But as we've seen before, you can always find bad bands on legit cigars. But not as much on EL's.
[Reply]
Drkns 02:45 PM 04-06-2012
Bobarian, interesting info much appreciated.
[Reply]
Drkns 02:59 PM 04-06-2012
Ryan, you are right about thinner black line on top of gold dots but gold dots are rather sharp on actual cigar. Blur is due to iphone shake. If that makes this cigar fake and I also think this is fake makes me very sad since this means fake is as good as the real one on appearance. Thank you.
[Reply]
BMack 03:57 PM 04-06-2012
Keep in mind the bands could be real and the cigar could be fake. The best way to know is to smoke it.
[Reply]
Drkns 04:11 PM 04-06-2012
Your absolutely right BMack. Thanks.
[Reply]
STEVE S 04:29 PM 04-06-2012
They all look Real to me!!!
[Reply]
Drkns 01:52 AM 04-07-2012
I know this thread is getting longer than it should be but I am thinking of asking the shop to show me boxes. What do you think I should look or note or does it make any difference?
[Reply]
Page 2 of 5
< 12 34 > Last »
Up