Brickhouse
San Lotano Oval
LP T52
AB Black Market
09 Camacho Liberty
[Reply]

Padron 3000 maduro
La Gloria Cubana Serie R
Oliva V
Oliva Master Blends 3
Rocky Patel Decade
[Reply]

Its hard to narrow it down to five but here we go.
AF Hemmingway Maduro
AF Anejo Shark or any other Anejo
LP Undercrown
Kristoff Maduro
Any Opus X with more than 3 years

Honorable mention goes to
AF 8-5-8 MAduro, for under $4.00 this is a steal
[Reply]

Oliva Studio Tobac STDS-001
Padron 1926 #1 Maduro
Liga Privada FFP
Tempus Maduro Magistri (original release)
Ashton ESG 20 year
[Reply]

LP No. 9 belicoso
LP T-52 toro
Oliva V torpedo
My Father No. 1
Padron 1926 80th Maduro
[Reply]

Padron 64 Exlusivo
Short story natrual
La auare 107
My father
Tatuaje
Not in any specific order.
[Reply]

Favorite sticks that are still in production and can still be purchased:

Epernay La Ferme
Old Henry Maduro, Corona
San Cristobal Elegencia, Robusto
DPG Blue, Corona or Firecracker
Illusione MK
[Reply]

El Triunfador #1 & #5
Tatuaje Red Band Victorias
Eperney Le Petit
Cain Daytona #4
Padron Palmas

Off the top of my head.
[Reply]

Oliva Serie V
Kristoff maduro
Liga Undercrown
Nica Libre Potencia
La Flor Dominicana Cabinet Ligero Oscuro
[Reply]

Oliva V
EDC New Wave Connecticut
Kristoff Ligero Maduro
Partagas Spanish Rosado
Torano Exodus 1959
[Reply]

In Order:
1. Davidoff Special R
2. Opus X- Any
3. Tat Fausto
4. Viaje Skull & Bones Daisy Cutter
5. Palio Esencia Belicoso
[Reply]

It is really hard to rank, so in no particular order :

1. Undercrown GT
2. GH Zulu
3. CAO Italia
4. Ashton VSG
5. Cain Daytona torp
[Reply]

In no particular order:

Ashton
AF Hemingway maduro
San Cristobal
La Riqueza
Oliva MB3

Chemyst :-)
[Reply]