Mine too! But by the box they are less than $3.00 per stick, and worth at least twice that!.
[Reply]

First I would like to say Its nice to have a new list now hopefully with help from everyone we could make a nice list bigger than tmax's old list. As a suggestion as in the tmax OP he included $4 dollar and i think $5 dollar smokes too.

I have 3 to add to the list if interested. First off EO #21 (I happen to be smoking one now) Good Cheap Mild-Med from the guys at United Tobacco at Ci they go for $35 to $40 for a bundle of 21 so that puts them at $1.90 for the most expensive sticks

Second and third as they are the same smoke only difference is one has ligero and the other does not. they are a Rocky Cigars House Blend (blended by DPG but as we all know he has stopped doing a lot of his house blends but they claim they kept the blend just new makers.) I like this cigar as it is Cheap and is a Corojo Wrapped Corillo Filled Cigar (pepin style blend without the pepin price) They go for $43 to $50 for a box of 25 and currently they are throwing in 5 extra for a total of 30. That puts the most exp boxes at $1.60 a stick.

Lastly Tat P's at least the Robusto and Corona Gorda vitolas the last time i got them though was before SCHIP so someone might have to check this with a call to Atlantic as the last time i got a box it was a box of 31 for $75 which makes it $2.40 a stick. This may not be correct still so with the schip i don't know if it will still make it under the $3 mark but i bet it still will cause with that box count it would have to cost more than $93 to go over the $3 mark. I actually think all Sizes of this smoke may make it. If you are weary of putting this on a list just shoot atlantic an email and they will send you the prices.

Sorry for the long post, Thanks for getting this thread going on this board!
[Reply]

the Fumadores by JPG are great for less than $2 most of the time. Holts runs them for $29.95 a box every other catalog.
[Reply]

I'd like to add petrus reposado to the list. They are very tasty and can be had for under $50 a box.
[Reply]

Oliva O #4
Indian Tabac Classic
Indian Tabac Classic Maduro
[Reply]

I was bored so I updated the list


5 Vegas "A"
5 Vegas Classic
5 Vegas Gold
826 Slow aged Perdomo
AF Curly Head Natural
Alcazar #4
Ashton Benchmade
Bahia Blu
CFO Reserva #7
Consuegra's
Cu-Avana Maduro
Cuba Libre
Diablo
Doc Holliday (Holts) (Thanks rharris)
Don Kiki brown
El Mejor Emerald
El Mejor Espresso
EO #21
Esteban Carrera Maduro
Evelio (Moms or JR's)
Famous Dom 5000
Famous Dominican 4000 (mild)
Famous Honduran 5000 (mild)
Famous Nic 3000
Famous Private Selection Nicaraguan Corojo
Fine Catch (Holts)
Fire Corojo
Fire Maduro
Flor de Oliva
Fumadores by JPG (holts)
Gispert
GR Specials
Gran Habanos 3 Siglos Fuma
Grand Habanos Corojo #5 Petite Corona
Gurkha Class Regent Nepalese Warriors
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend
Indian Tabac Classic
Indian Tabac Classic Maduro
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Maduro
JR Cuban Alternative Cohiba Sig IV
JR Ultimates
La Floridita (entire line)
La Vieja Habana (med)
Leoninos by La Aurora
Liga C & A X outs
Little Havana Overrun
Maria Mancini
Mayorga
Muniemaker
Nestor Reserve Maduro
Oliva G special G (mad & nat)
Oliva O #4
Padillia Obsidian Belicoso
Padron Delicias
Padron Londres
Partagas Black Pronto
Perdomo Fresco
Perdomo Fresh-Rolled Wheels (med)
Petrus reposado
Punch London Club
Punch Rothschild Double Maduro
R.P Vintage seconds
REO
Rocky Cigars House Blend
RP Factory Selects
Saint Luis Rey maddies
Sancho Panza Double maduro
Sol Cubana Cuban Cabinet
SPEF Cordoba
Taboo Value Line
Tampa Sweethearts
Tatuaje Series P
Tierra del Sol
Vega Talanga Tercio Corona
Vegas de Santiago originales
Vegas de Santiago puros
Vigilante Petite Corona Corojo
[Reply]

This thread should be pinned, to avoid duplicate threads.

Chemyst :-)
[Reply]

**UPDATE**

3 Bucks and under


5 Vegas "A"
5 Vegas Classic
5 Vegas Gold
826 Slow aged Perdomo
AF Curly Head Natural
Alcazar #4
Ashton Benchmade
Aspira Corojo
Bahia Blu
CFO Reserva #7
Consuegra's
Cu-Avana Maduro
Cuba Libre
Diablo
Doc Holliday (Holts) (Thanks rharris)
Don Kiki brown
El Mejor Emerald
El Mejor Espresso
EO #21
Esteban Carrera Maduro
Evelio (Moms or JR's)
Famous Dom 5000
Famous Dominican 4000 (mild)
Famous Honduran 5000 (mild)
Famous Nic 3000
Famous Private Selection Nicaraguan Corojo
Fine Catch (Holts)
Fire Corojo
Fire Maduro
Flor de Oliva
Fumadores by JPG (holts)
Gispert
GR Specials
Gran Habanos 3 Siglos Fuma
Grand Habanos Corojo #5 Petite Corona
Gurkha Class Regent Nepalese Warriors
Indian Tabac Cameroon Legend
Indian Tabac Classic
Indian Tabac Classic Maduro
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Maduro
JR Cuban Alternative Cohiba Sig IV
JR Ultimates
La Floridita (entire line)
La Vieja Habana (med)
Leoninos by La Aurora
Liga C & A X outs
Little Havana Overrun
Maria Mancini
Mayorga
Muniemaker
Nestor Reserve Maduro
Oliva G special G (mad & nat)
Oliva O #4
Onyx
Padillia Obsidian Belicoso
Padron Delicias
Padron Londres
Partagas Black Pronto
Perdomo Fresco
Perdomo Fresh-Rolled Wheels (med)
Petrus reposado
Punch London Club
Punch Rothschild Double Maduro
R.P Vintage seconds
REO
Rocky Cigars House Blend
RP Factory Selects
Saint Luis Rey maddies
Sancho Panza Double maduro
Sol Cubana Cuban Cabinet
SPEF Cordoba
Taboo Value Line
Tampa Sweethearts
Tatuaje Series P
Tierra del Sol
Vega Talanga Tercio Corona
Vegas de Santiago originales
Vegas de Santiago puros
Vigilante Petite Corona Corojo

[Reply]

$2.25 retail (in KY) for a Pepin made cigar!! Life is good my friends.

Tabacos Baez Series S F (short filler) is my new favorite morning smoke. I pulled apart a nub and would guess the cigar has 3 full size leaves and the rest is sandwiched clippings. The cigar holds ash quite well so I have no concern enjoying them in my car.
[Reply]

From Holts

Black Sheep - http://www.holts.com/category.html?i...1&trail=201628

Argyle - http://www.holts.com/category.html?i...72&trail=86665

I bought them not expecting a good smoke and was really surprised.

Dan
[Reply]

I'd like to add the Cu-Avana Intenso. Ver good.

MCS
[Reply]

I like the Argyles as well..
[Reply]

Just got in a box of DA VINCI MASTERPIECE. I only paid $2.20 each for these with shipping. I'm getting hooked on cigar auctions.
[Reply]

Some really good budget smokes on this list. Figured I'd bump it for the newbs. :-)

Some of my favorites from the list:

5 Vegas "A"
5 Vegas Gold
Consuegra's
El Mejor Emerald
Famous Nic 3000
Flor de Oliva
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Maduro
Nestor Reserve Maduro
Padron Londres
Tampa Sweethearts
Tatuaje Series P

And I want to add a Famous Honduran to the list, but it's been a while since I had one and can't remember which X000 line it was. I know it was a Maduro wrapper. :-)
[Reply]

No one has said "Fumadores" which are a sandwich cigar from DPG. Damn that guy makes some great cigars. I believe they are a Holt's exclusive.
[Reply]

Actually...

:-)
[Reply]

Joel hit the nail on the head with these...some of my favorites!! :-)

Famous Nic 3000
Flor de Oliva Maduro
Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Maduro
Tampa Sweethearts #500s
[Reply]

I stand corrected, I am glad the Fumadores weren't missed they are a great inexpensive cigar.

Any one ever have Carlos Torano Dominicos Maduro's. I like most all the Torano stuff so I picked up a box of 25 for 31 bucks. I am sure there no 59 gold but I'm gonna give them a shot.
[Reply]

I bought a bundle of the Little Havana Overruns (Pepin made) yesterday (which I smoked one) and it was GREAT! Best $2 cigar I've ever had!
[Reply]

Just picked up 3 more bundles of the LHOs. 2 coronas bundles and 1 robusto bundle. They are starting to run low on the coronas. Pick them up now if you like that size
[Reply]