When do you own a box? - Page 4 - Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum

Only if the box is full 43 37.07%

1+ cigars(s) have been consumed 33 28.45%

Addiction's definition is wack!! 46 39.66%

My theory is, if you bought the full box, you own it. Does not matter how many you have smoked.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by skibumdc:
According to Addiction's wording, if you consume 1 cigar out of a box, you no longer have a BOX.

For example, he has 5 full intact boxes of Cohiba Reservas, and 1 open box.

Now MOST of us would say he has 6 boxes, but Addiction is VERY specific in his wording and says he only has 5 boxes.

Is his math or wording correct?

If his wording is true, then I only have 3 boxes.

I tried using that Fuzzy Math with my wife Image Image Image
Yeah, she didn't buy it.

So, if I open a PSD4 box and consume 1 or 2 cigars, do I still have a box?

Originally Posted by shilala:
A box of cigars is a box of cigars if it's full of the cigars that came in it.
If it's been opened, then it's a full open box of cigars.
If I sell a box of 2006 Anejos and some are 2005, it ain't a box of 2006 Anejos.
Once it's empty, it's just a box.
For me, it's time to get another box once the first one comes out. That way the others are getting ready for when the open box is getting smoked.
I'm not sure what MOBD is talking about, but if it's a train full of cigars, I get to cherry pick. I called it first. :-)

Originally Posted by icehog3:
25 sticks in the box = A box

24 sticks in the box = A partial box

If I have a box of 25 cigars and I take one out I have a partial box of cigars, but if my wife sees me take the first cigar out of the box I have a question; "and when did you buy that one!":-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by brigey57:
If I have a box of 25 cigars and I take one out I have a partial box of cigars, but if my wife sees me take the first cigar out of the box I have a question; "and when did you buy that one!":-)

:-) :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Blueface:
Well then, since you don't have that many boxes, that means you can shove them all up your ..... as they will fit better now.:-)

That's one way to get the Cuban barnyard smell :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by n3uka:
That's one way to get the Cuban barnyard smell :-)

but only if your ... is Cuban
[Reply]

I fully admit Bryan is right if you are counting boxes in terms of the ability to sell.
For me, who does not intend to sell partial boxes, if I purchase and smoke a few out of the box, I still consider myself having a box.

Just my opinion
[Reply]

For me: (ok I may be splitting hairs here)

I have a full box until it has been opened.

I have a partial box until I move the remaining gars to the singles drawer.
[Reply]

I wish I could amuse myself as easily as the op :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by okieRob:
For me: (ok I may be splitting hairs here)

I have a full box until it has been opened.

I have a partial box until I move the remaining gars to the singles drawer.

that sounds pretty fair.
[Reply]