Some of my favorites:
www.leafandale.com
www.cordovacigars.com
www.newhavanacigars.com
www.cigarsinternational.com
www.famous-smoke.com

Scott
[Reply]

I just wanted to thank everyone for their suggestions...I think I have found a new favorite cigar retailer- Famous Smoke Shop....the layout of their website is straightforward and easy to navigate, their prices are competitive, and I really like the free shipping on many items...I picked up some everyday smokes last night; a bundle of supervisor selection and a bundle of famous nic 3000's...
I can't wait to try them!
[Reply]

I agree totally. Love em. :-)
[Reply]

Booyah
[Reply]

Dead heat between Famous and Cigars International. :-)
[Reply]

I think CI has the best deals and changes them often enough for me to think i've struck gold more frequently.
[Reply]

I also like the fact that Famous Smoke shop lists ALL customer reviews on cigars....not just the positive reviews....I posted a review on CI several months ago, albeit a negative one, and was censored....>:-) they didn't even post it! I think most adults are smart enough to read reviews, both negative and positive, and formulate their own opinion...I think that allowing both negative and positive reviews on retailer's websites increases their crediblity and transparency.....
[Reply]

Well, I am not sure I have a favorite....in fact, I don't. That said, I just made my first oline cigar purchase and CI got my business.

I was bouncing between Holts, CJ and FS....but I wanted a box of Alec Bradley Tempus Terra Nova's. FS didn't have them, Holt's and CI was the same price, got a throw in from CI and that was that.....

Best thing, I saved $50 from what my B&M wanted for a box.
[Reply]

Atlantic and Cigarplace

Mike at Leaf and Ale is great too!!!
[Reply]

New Havana - great customer service
Taboo - excellent customer service and some really good deals
Atlantic - good prices if you call
Jack Schwartz - some great deals on the Friday Special
[Reply]

How do I go about getting the coupons from Taboo?
[Reply]

AFAIK, just sign up on their website:
http://www.taboocigars.com/
[Reply]

What, no Thompson's customers here? :-)

I get virtually all my cigars from JRs. Lew carries what I like, has a price I can (barely, but still) afford, gives very good customer service that is rarely needed, and - and, I repeat, and - does not push some product he cannot supply. As I've seen complaints on here from some of you regarding backorders or cancelled orders, or orders just ignored, this should count a point or three.
[Reply]

http://www.thepartysource.com

Eric and Micah have the best prices and customer service. Haven't found anyone who can beat their prices across the board. :-)

:-) Booyah! :-)
[Reply]

JR, CI, and egars are the three that I go to first.
[Reply]

I mainly use four vendors:
Atlantic
Best Cigar Prices
Cigars International
Cheaper Cigars
[Reply]

I have bought from CI, Cigar Bid, Famous, and Cigar monster, and Rocky's Cigars. I have had very good luck with all of them, I really liked the personalized service from Rockys and their prices are great especially for being a little guy
[Reply]

So far, I am extremely impressed with Famous Smoke Shop,....I love the layout of their website, and selection of their cigars....I also LOVE the monster deal....it changes every hour! is that sweet or what? I placed an order with them on Sunday, and got my stogies on Wednesday...Got a bundle of the Famous Nicaraguan 3000's and smoked one on the way to work...wow...I was quite impressed for it being a $2.00 smoke
[Reply]

I do not even look at Famous or CI anymore now that I have found cigarplace.biz. They are so much cheaper on most brands.
[Reply]

Like what? i checked several brands and they seem comparable....do they offer free shipping?
[Reply]