I'd have to vote for Cuesta-Rey Centenario. Gerry (zemekone) turned me on to these and I think CI's description is spot on.
"Cuesta Rey is a medium bodied cigar with a creamy flavor. Made with Dominican long-filler and Connecticut or Cameroon wrappers. Well-aged and smooth."
[Reply]
I agree with the suggestions of Fuente. Anything Sungrown, Hemingway, or green label is very tasty, easy on the wallet, and palatable for a novice.
Also I was a big fan of Padron 0000 series, CAO anything, and Rocky Patel particularly Old Worlde Reserve when I was starting out. If you can spring for an Oliva Master Blends that is a great balanced and flavorful cigar.
[Reply]