You are from the Cincinnati area and you don't like Graeter's? BLASPHEMY! :-)
[Reply]

I like whatever's in the freezer as long as it doesn't have peanut butter in it and it ain't freezer burned.
[Reply]

But I do, I do! It's just that the H-D Macadamia Nut Brittle is my fav.:-)
[Reply]

Ahhh.... I see my friend. All is well between you and I again :-) :-)
[Reply]

Moose Trax... Cookie dough would be a good 2nd
[Reply]

Grape:-)
[Reply]

Häagen-Dazs RUM Raisin Nuff said
[Reply]

:-) My favorite "store-bought" ice cream - hands down.

If I could have any ice cream I wanted? Home-made peach. Wow. :-)
[Reply]

If you have the opportunity I would highly recommend trying Handel's Homemade Ice Cream.
[Reply]

There's a place by the name of Spotted Dog Creamery here, and they make a Huckleberry Chip that is absolutely fantastic.
[Reply]

Rum Rasin...got to get the real stuff, none of that low fat no sugar added crap!
[Reply]

Cold Stone Creamery Cheesecake ice cream. I don't eat a lot of ice cream, but when I do this is my fave.


And pretty much anything but Ben & Jerry's
[Reply]

My wife's family lives near what I believe is the original Handels in the Cleveland area. Their ice cream is hands down the best I have ever tasted. The grape, blueberry cheesecake, and chocolate pecan are all awesome.
[Reply]

My favorite USED to be the black cherry flavor that the Clemson Univeristy AG organization would make up and sell. It was delicious, rich, creamy, flavorful, and fresh. A few years back, due to rising demand, they outsourced the production to (I think) Mayfield. I'm not sure if they're making it themselves again, but the ice cream never recovered :-)
[Reply]

Peachy Paterno

http://www.creamery.psu.edu/flavors.htm
[Reply]

Homemade peach is my favorite and we had it for the 4th!!
[Reply]

Melon bars FTW. My wife keeps usually has a box of them in the freezer.
[Reply]

Ben & Jerry's brownie Batter it's a good mess!
[Reply]

Breyers or Basket Robbins.
[Reply]

I always seems to fall back on Mint Chocolate Chip.
[Reply]