The best I've had was a '90's Cohiba Lancero. It was simply amazing. :-)
[Reply]

my 98 R&J churchills :-)
[Reply]

Arturo Fuente - Work of Art (Maduro)
[Reply]

I've only had one (robusto) and I'm not sure which it was. It was gifted to me.
[Reply]

I love my Padron Anniversary and Tatuaje Cojonu but an Opus X with 3-5 years on it is very hard to beat.
[Reply]

I did not like them rott. But after a year of rest they are a whole different cigar. I'm thinking the entire s&b line will be similar, as far as my tastes are concerned. And I have no problems resting them for a year.
Posted via Mobile Device
[Reply]

NC: OR Dirty Rat CC: '04 Boli GM
[Reply]

Ashton VSG.
[Reply]

1980 Monte #2. Smoked them with my uncle in July 1993.
[Reply]

Not really sure but I would have to put the LP#9 up in the top two right now for me
[Reply]

Cohiba Lancero for me as well :-)
[Reply]

Taboada Sublime.
[Reply]

Anejo Shark always knocks my socks off.
[Reply]

I'm getting in this lline. :-)

If they are all out, the 1994.
[Reply]

If I could choose a number one without ever smoking it, this would be it.
[Reply]

The best #1 I have had is an '01 Monte Especial #1
[Reply]

This. I might answer this question different every month.

However, as to OP, I'd never suggest that my number one cigar was one which I'd never tried. More often than not, I'm 'disappointed' by a cigar that I've built up in my mind. Guess that is good -- while there are always cigars out there that I think I'd like to try, I don't salivate or get overly excited about anything new to me.
[Reply]

My ultimate fav is the 1926 Padron, second was the Partagas black label.
[Reply]

Padron 80th.
[Reply]

"Someday (We'll Be Together)" - Diana Ross & The Supremes
[Reply]