Illusione CG4
Man o War Runination corona
LP T52 toro
EPC New Wave robusto
LFD DL Maduro Chiselito

* Ask me again next week, this list could look different
[Reply]

MOW Puro Authentico
601 Blue
San Cristobal
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Maduro
JdN Antano
[Reply]

Tat Anarchy
Liga Privada No 9
Illusione Holy Lance
Tat Black PL
Panacea Black Perfecto Maduro
[Reply]

1. Kristoff
2. RyJ
3. Graycliff 1666
4. AF ss
5. DPG Firecracker
[Reply]

These are the first 5 that came to mind from my current line-up. In no particular order:
Anejo Shark- or any other Anejo.
AF Hemmingway Signature
LP #9
Ashton Aged Maduro
Opus X Super Belicoso

I could not stop at 5 sorry:
Kristoff Maduro
WOAM
Opus Perfexion #4
AF Queen B
AF 8-5-8 Maduro- Great budget stick
Padron 2000/3000 Maduro- Great budget stick
[Reply]

1. Tatuaje 7th Reserva
2. Tatuaje Black petit lancero
3. Padron 1926 Maduro #2
4. Liga Privada T52 toro
5. Tatuaje NHC Capa Especial
[Reply]

PAM Anni's (64 and 26)
Anejo
DPG Maduro
Litto Gomez Diez, his LGD line, not LFD. They suck.
Don Carlos Anniversario
El Original Toro Maduro

Those are standouts I can think of off the top of my head. I couldn't trim one off, I tried. Probably the best NC I ever smoked was an 08 DPG Maduro or a PAM 26 #6 from the same year. I've smoked blue band Oliva O's that were right up there, too.
[Reply]

How do the '64 and '26 compare? Ive only had the '64 so I'm curious about the differences.

My top 5 are
Padron '64 maduro
Padron 5000 maduro
DPG Blue
Oliva Serie O
AF Hemingway SS

I'm pretty new to the hobby so this list will likely change but these are my favorites at the moment.
[Reply]

Hemingway Maduro, any size save for the WOAM
PAM 64, fresh. I like the little extra kick of spice you get fresh
LP #9 Toro.
EPC Core Line Club 52
Kristoff Maduro

As you can see I like my maduros and toros
[Reply]

Lots of great CC's out there....more or less in order;

• Pretty anything that says "Padron" on it
• Pretty much anything from Don Pepin
• Tatuaje Brown Labels (which is also from Don Pepin, essentially).....
• Liga Privada #9's
• Undercrown

[Reply]

Padron 80th
Padron 45
Tat Black CG
Tat T110
LFD small batch #1
[Reply]

After only smoking for a year if I had to pick a top 5 this would be it. Nothing has matched the LP9 for me yet, but who knows, seems like I am smoking a new stick daily! :-)

1. Liga Privada 9
2. Tatuaje Brown label
3. Undercrown
4. Arturo Fuente Hemmingway
5. 601 Blue Label Maduro
[Reply]

This week's list:

1) Tatuaje Cojonu 2003
2) Tat black lancero
3) La Aurora 107
4) Padron Londres
5) Fausto, any size
[Reply]

1. 601 Blue
2. Viaje Holiday Blend
3. DPG JJ Series Maduro
4. Lig Pirvada #9
5. Any size blue banded Oliva
[Reply]

All time?
1. Opus
2. Aged Opus
3. Fresh Opus
4. Wet Opus
5. ROT Opus


Currently:

1. GAR
2. Saint Miguel
3. Cabiguan
4. Camacho (the one with the white band)
5. HemmingWay Maduro
[Reply]

Perdomo Champagne Noir
Perdomo Habano
Perdomo Lot 23
Nub Maduro
Oliva G
[Reply]

1) My Father #1
2) Illusione CG4
3) Arturo Fuente 858 natural
4) Alec Bradley Family Blend
5) Alec Bradley Tempus Maduro
[Reply]

Hmmm...

2010 VOR
Tat Black PL
Skull and Bones Fat Man
2011 VOR
Illusione Epernay

Man, 5 isn't enough.
[Reply]

Fuente Anejo Shark (2010)
Tatuaje Pork Tenderloin (2010)
Viaje Exclusivo Robusto (2010)
Illusione HL Candela (2011)
Viaje Satori (2010)

In no particular order.
[Reply]

In no particular order:

San Cristobal
Oliva MB 3
La Riqueza
Pepin JJ maduro
Fuente Hemi maduro

This is my current rotation.

Chemyst :-)
[Reply]