Do you use a cutter or a punch? - Page 2 - Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum

Cutter 52 54.74%

Punch 9 9.47%

I use both regularly. 34 35.79%

Originally Posted by Don Fernando:
Punch unless i smoke a torpedo or a lancero

This. But I punch Lanceros too :-)

Never had a tar problem.
[Reply]

I only have a cutter, every time I think about getting a punch, I end up spending $$ on sticks.
Posted via Mobile Device
[Reply]

I've been using strictly a cutter for awhile but recently picked up a punch after using Bill86's a couple weeks ago. I'm really enjoy the punch now but my cutter was cheap and that may have something to do with it.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by kelmac07:
Cutter all day for me. :-) I used to use a punch when I first started, but the tar build up was a big turn-off.

I love the punch but for reasons stated above I like the cutter as a better option. :-)
[Reply]

Been on a punch kick since I bought a vector key chain punch for $5
Posted via Mobile Device
[Reply]

I use a guillotine everytime, but want to get a punch to see the difference. I wlll have to make this more of a priority.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Bageland2000:
I love the way a punched cigar feels vs a cut, and I haven't really experienced the tar build up that others around here have. That's just personal preference though, I can't really say specifically what I like about it, it's just feel.

Same here. Once I first discovered the punch, On a trip to Mexico.. I was sold.

Originally Posted by Lanks85:
I use a guillotine everytime, but want to get a punch to see the difference. I wlll have to make this more of a priority.

CI, CBID Always have deals.. For a couple.
[Reply]

I almost exclusively use my v-cut
[Reply]

I loved my punch until Scott showed me the way of an awesome cutter, have been using that religiously now.
[Reply]

I am a fan of punch. I use to use a cutter, but for some reason when I tried the punch cutter I made a new friend. I love the way the draw is with it, every so often I will use a cutter.
[Reply]

I have a punch in my car as a backup, but I don't remember the last time I used it. I use my Palio most of the time, and occasionally break out my Xikar v-cut when the mood strikes me.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by kelmac07:
Cutter all day for me. :-) I used to use a punch when I first started, but the tar build up was a big turn-off.

+1 for me. I stick with cutters. Just ordered a precision cutter, in fact.
[Reply]

Usually a punch unless it's a figurado....then the cutter.
[Reply]

I use my Palio each and every time.

:-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Sonic04GT:
What do you use the most or does it vary greatly on the type of cigar?

I bought a punch recently and have only used it once. I think I like the tighter draw more with the punch that with a standard guillotine cutter. But I'm a noob so I don't know what I'm talking about.

I know some cigars, like the Drew Estate Java with a rectangular shape would be very difficult to get a clean cut.

Since you asked...

I use both but it depends greatly on the ring gauge of the cigar or how much smoke and flavor I derive from the brand of cigar. I prefer a cutter but I have clippers, punch, v-cutter, guillotine, and xi-car cutters and generally use the xi-car first and the punch secondarily.

You say you don't know what you're talking about but I think you know what you like and why you like it, so that is the rule that I follow too.

The most important part is you know what you enjoy.

With the Drew cigar I would use the V-cutter to put a nice notch at teh end of the cigar versus a punch, but it's all good. :-)

Go for it and enjoy 8-{b}
[Reply]

Originally Posted by SmokeyJoe:
I always use them, except when I don't.

Of course... this only happens if I am by myself or with somebody.

:-)

Nice...LOL
[Reply]