I love Edmund Fitzgerald. on tap or out of a bottle?


good beer, great cigar.
[Reply]

Great review, one of my absolute favorite NC's.
[Reply]

Out of a bottle. Just started homebrewing, and would love to find a clone recipe for the beer.
[Reply]

Ditto here.

9's or 52's can't go wrong either way.

Stocking up Monday on both while the gettin's good!:-)
[Reply]

Erv, are you Tuck's buddy? Sorry I missed you at Boilers herf!
[Reply]

great review brother, I prefer the 9's to the 52's, but still a good cigar.
[Reply]

You need to try the Dirty Rat if you haven't yet. One of my favorites!
[Reply]

This is the cigar that was cigar #4 in my blind review lineup going on.
[Reply]

Big fan of this blend. SO SO much better than the t9. I think the robousto( i think its that size :-)) is better, but size is a preference:-)
[Reply]

Any similarities to the #9? what are some differences? I tried a #9 tonight and it was the best cigar I have smoked! I immediately talked my neighbor into ordering a 5r and splitting me one.
I see alot of people commented they prefer the 9s, anybody go the other way besides the last post any why?
[Reply]

I would decribe the T-52 as a #9 light. If you enjoyed but T-52 and lean towards a more full-bodied smoke, the #9 will blow your mind! I've got a box of #9s that are so good as-is that it's hard to let them age...but I'm trying to show restraint. As my friend has decreibed them, they're like a steak dinner transformed into a cigar. Mmm, mmm, good! :-)
[Reply]

The T-52 and the No.9 are similar, the No.9 is more earthy and the T-52 is more spicy. Body and depth of flavor are about the same. I happen to prefer the T-52, the PA stalk cut habano capa is unique and tastes as such.
[Reply]

Great review this has become my number 2 stick....yummmy
[Reply]