Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
Entertainment>Shutter Island (2010)
LasciviousXXX 10:06 AM 02-19-2010
Originally Posted by JE3146:
Not to totally dismiss your rating, but 3.5 stars doesn't scream 'must see' :-)

Any reason for the 3.5?

Having said that, I've been looking foreword to this film for a while now.
I guess I should explain my own personal rating system. Since I watch so many movies and have a grip-load at home as well I'm pretty stringent when it comes to rating a movie.

Most movie offerings fall in the 2-2.5 stars rating for me. Throw away movies like Legion and the upcoming Cop Out (originally titled "A Couple of Dicks") are average forgettable movies and usually get a 2 or a 2.5 from me.

Above average movies are a 3 and above average that I think deserve a theatre visit get a 3.5

A 4 means I'll prob see it 2-3 times in the theatre and a 5 means by the time I review it I've seen it half a dozen times in the theatres, have downloaded a cam-rip that I burned to DVD and will purchase the movie on Blu Ray when it comes out and am planning where on my body to put a movie tattoo :-)
[Reply]
Kreth 11:55 AM 02-19-2010
Originally Posted by LasciviousXXX:
...and am planning where on my body to put a movie tattoo :-)
You have an I Heart Huckabees tattoo, don't you? :-)
Posted via Mobile Device
[Reply]
LasciviousXXX 12:32 PM 02-19-2010
Its next to my "Breakin' 2 Electric Boogaloo" tat :-)
[Reply]
Kreth 12:42 PM 02-19-2010
Originally Posted by LasciviousXXX:
Its next to my "Breakin' 2 Electric Boogaloo" tat :-)
:-) :-) :-)
Posted via Mobile Device
[Reply]
CigarNut 01:06 PM 02-19-2010
Originally Posted by LasciviousXXX:
Its next to my "Breakin' 2 Electric Boogaloo" tat :-)
And that is next to your tat of Kevin Bacon in Footloose, right?
[Reply]
aich75013 01:14 PM 02-19-2010
I hate to put the thread back on topic, but ...

I saw the preview yesterday. Looks interesting.
[Reply]
rlmedic 01:22 PM 02-19-2010
Really looking forward to seeing it...read the book it was great
[Reply]
kaisersozei 07:53 PM 02-19-2010
I'm interested to see how faithfully the movie captures the book. Great read!
[Reply]
Darrell 01:22 AM 02-20-2010
Good movie. Official review tomorrow.
[Reply]
Starscream 09:01 AM 02-20-2010
Originally Posted by Adriftpanda:
It was horrendous. I seriously fell asleep for a good 10 min.

And THIS movie, I am looking forward to it! I might try to get a midnight showing. This looks very good.
You did better than me. I went to sleep for over an hour in the theater trying to watch Wolfman.
[Reply]
GreekGodX 09:22 AM 02-20-2010
Can't wait to hear what you guys thought.. I definitely want to see this! No spoilers tho please :-)
[Reply]
Adriftpanda 10:30 AM 02-20-2010
Originally Posted by andysutherland:
You did better than me. I went to sleep for over an hour in the theater trying to watch Wolfman.
Haha I don't blame ya man.


Gonna see this movie tomorrow. Can't wait. It has gotten some good reviews.
[Reply]
Darrell 12:18 PM 02-20-2010
As usual, no spoilers.

Leonardo DiCaprio is Deputy U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels, he and his partner Chuck are dispatched to Shutter Island, a maximum security mental institution on an island off the coast of Boston to investigate the disappearance of a dangerous mental patient. What comes next is a mind **** of twists and turns, some, which were a little obvious, and others that were totally unexpected.

Leo was on top of his game in this and played a completely believable character (you will see why I say believable when you watch the movie). Mark Ruffalo played Deputy U.S. Marshal Chuck Aule and paired with DiCaprio they made a perfect team. There was a ton a charisma between the two of them. The plot is rock solid and Martin Scorsese I believe really came out of his comfort zone with this film, it says Scorsese, but not in the sense the Departed did. It’s very different and it would be great to see him further branch out like he did with Shutter Island.

The score for this movie was perfect. Their were some pretty dramatic scenes and a few that were spooky as well, the music at times made me think the hair on my neck was going to stand up at any minute. I heard a few people say they fell asleep during this movie, that it was Leonardo DiCaprio’s worst film, etc. I don’t think that could be further from the truth, in fact I would venture to say that was one of his BEST performances to date. I would love to see Scorsese, DiCaprio, and Ruffalo back on the screen together for another film.

I give this 4.5 out of 5 stars.

[Reply]
hotreds 02:17 PM 02-20-2010
Just saw this and would agree that it was very good altho- and I won't continue for those who have not seen it.
[Reply]
Darrell 12:14 PM 02-21-2010
Did anyone else see it?
[Reply]
eber 12:22 PM 02-21-2010
I am going this afternoon, will post my thoughts after
[Reply]
NeuRon 12:43 PM 02-21-2010
Im going to see it this week..

I find it interesting how so many people dislike DiCaprio.. sure he looks like some little panzie that used to get beat up in high school. But all BS aside, he is a VERY talented actor..
[Reply]
King James 02:52 PM 02-21-2010
I saw it last night and thought it was awesome. I would agree with the mind **** element of it. After it ended it was just like what the hell did I just see, but in the very best way possible.
[Reply]
Darrell 10:36 PM 02-21-2010
Originally Posted by King James:
I saw it last night and thought it was awesome. I would agree with the mind **** element of it. After it ended it was just like what the hell did I just see, but in the very best way possible.
Yeah, I had to tell Danielle my thoughts to see if she agreed, to make sure I was on the right track.
[Reply]
eber 10:53 PM 02-21-2010
Originally Posted by King James:
I saw it last night and thought it was awesome. I would agree with the mind **** element of it. After it ended it was just like what the hell did I just see, but in the very best way possible.
:-)

I just saw it tonight and I thought it was incredible, stellar performances from all cast members IMO it is awesome when you leave a movie and look at your watch and go "wow I didn't know this was that long!!!" never once did I get bored. I highly recommend it!!!
[Reply]
Page 2 of 3
< 12 3 >
Up