Right now I would have to say the two that stand out in my mind as the best I've had were my very first Boli PC and my very first Anejo #49
[Reply]

I won't swear it was the best ever, but the Cohiba Siglo VI tubo I had while at the Phillies World Series Championship parade down Broad Street was mighty fine and quite memorable last Halloween.
[Reply]

Hands Down, Boli GM!:-)
[Reply]

Hands down, 1970's Monte #2 Dunhill Selection.
[Reply]

:-) Thats somethin that pops up in my dreams :-)

aj
[Reply]

Too many to list but the most recent stick has to be a Litto Gomez Small Batch #2. That cigar was so good it was shocking. I just remember thinking all along how I couldn't believe I'd never heard of it till a buddy gifted it to me.
[Reply]

This is kind of shocking to me, EVERYONE I have spoken with about these sticks say the 2's are horrible compared to the 1 and the 3. Glad you enjoy them :-)
[Reply]

01 Upmann #2 or LCG MdO #1
[Reply]

I never got to try them fresh. So my experience is only with them aged for quite some time and they rock!
[Reply]

RASCC would be my morning cigar, Lunch Cigar LGC MdO #3, Dinner Trinidad Fundadores, and for the hell of it a Tatuaje T110
[Reply]

I will keep that in mind, My B & M has a bunch of these in stock. I will try one tonight.
[Reply]

Let me know your opinion on it!:-)
[Reply]

80's Davidoff 5000 (Cuban)
[Reply]

Sitting on one of these...tempts me every day!! :-)
[Reply]

Tough one. I've had a number of very memorable stogies. I had several Party Ds from the same batch that really blew me away. I had an 80s vintage R&J Churchill that was simply outstanding, having had enough time to really get some character. I had several Montes that were a decade or two old that I thought were particularly tasty. I'll go with that old R&J.
[Reply]

Agreed, to date in my smoking career, the boris is hands down my favorite cigar.
Scott
[Reply]

1950s Blackstone
[Reply]

Off the top of my head thats the one that comes to mind :-) I need to find more :-)
[Reply]

1980 Montecristo #2.
[Reply]

H Upmann No.2 from 1990, simply amazing. I was sitting on the lake in northern Wisconsin this past summer when I smoked this. Great experience overall:-)
[Reply]