I have only had the V, been wanting to try the others.....:-) I think I do have an O in my humi though.
[Reply]

You don't have to have a great palate to appreciate any smoke, especially those 64 anny maduros. That was either my second or third cigar ever and instantly became my favorite. Nowadays its dropped back to second in my top 5, but its a very close second. You'll appreciate it more down the road yes, but that doesn't mean you should avoid it altogether for the time being. A great cigar is a great cigar, regardless of how experienced your palate is. :-)
[Reply]

The O naturals are like a little cinnamon bomb(or at least thats what I remember mine being). :-)
[Reply]

Interesting...:-)
[Reply]

I would recommend the following:
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Don Pepin Garcia Blue Label
Liga Privada T52
Oliva Serie V
Padron x000
:-)
[Reply]

Awesome advice guys! I feel like a kid on Christmas Eve - can't wait to go shopping! :-):-):-)
[Reply]

yea.. about that... I read one of these threads a month ago or so and made a list... ended up dropping about 120 in the B&M... granted he gave me a coupe free sticks since Im always in there and I rarely walk out with out dropping at least 50.... So be careful!! :-)
[Reply]

As a fellow newbie, I'd recommend My Father Le Bijou. It was the first cigar I could detect specific favors beyond sweet or spicy.
[Reply]

Honestly, I'd be happy with 120. I have a feeling it's going to be an expensive afternoon.
[Reply]

Forget lists. Start at one end of a shelf in you local b&m and work your way around the humidor, trying everything.

:-)
[Reply]

I had one this last week, amazing cigar! Instant top ten for me!
[Reply]

I have seriously thought about doing this.
[Reply]

This is a good list. My updates in red.
[Reply]

You cant beat "Brickhouse" for the price. Around $5 for the Robusto!
Awsome cigar and one of my all time favorites
[Reply]

Agreed Travis, this is on my "must have box" list whenever I get $$
[Reply]

I'll add:
AF 8-5-8 Maduro
Kristoff Maduro
AF Hemmingway
[Reply]

Had one of these the other day, I'll definitely be buying more!
[Reply]

Well, here's what I ended up getting. They had some Olivia reps there, so I got a free Nub Connecticut for buying 5 Nub/Cain/Olivia sticks, and then I won 2 more of them in a drawing they had. :-)

One of the Short Stories didn't make it out of the store :-) Damn fine little smoke.

1:
Image

2:
Image

3:
Image
[Reply]

:-) Nice selection there! Oliva V Beli and MF Le Bijou are two of my favorites.
[Reply]

That is a damn fine haul! So many to sample, but those should keep you busy for some time.

You should check out the newbie trade thread also. I am almost ready to participate in it myself.
[Reply]