Go with something light - I'm thinking a corona-sized Macanudo or Baccarat. The Monte white is also a good choice. The last thing you want is a couple of guys that have been in the sauce to suddenly fall ill to nic over-indulgence. I'm sure with all the laughter and carefreeness, more inhalation than is warranted will occur. Best to play it safe. The Baccarats also have a sweet tip which is pleasant for a non-smoker. For your buddy, it may be best to save the better smoke for him to enjoy with you later. Give him one of your lighter smokes that you enjoy. That way you can compare flavor profiles.
[Reply]
If you like Oliva, then why don't you just stick to that? They have plenty of cheaper/smaller cigars, so why look to nasty yard gars when Oliva sells cheap enough cigars?
[Reply]