Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 2 of 4
< 12 34 >
All Cigar Discussion>Your Oldest Cigar
BroncoHorvath 07:26 PM 08-25-2009
1998's Punch Punch that I found in Cuba in 2007 in Cienfuegos. I smoked my last 1996 JL No2 about a month ago....They were delicious.
[Reply]
Scottw 08:07 PM 08-25-2009
Originally Posted by markem:
I have a selection of cigars from 1917-1919 gifted to me, but doubt that I will ever smoke. Of the ones I do smoke, the 1857 Robt. Burns panatelas are stellar.
Do you have any pics of the Robt. Burns? It would be something to see.

U have a stick (el producto) from 1926 that I will smoke on my 50th birthday when it is 100 and I have a few boxes of 98 Punch Coronas.

PS, I am dying to see Klugs response to this question
[Reply]
markem 08:08 PM 08-25-2009
Originally Posted by Scottw:
Do you have any pics of the Robt. Burns? It would be something to see.

U have a stick (el producto) from 1926 that I will smoke on my 50th birthday when it is 100 and I have a few boxes of 98 Punch Coronas.

PS, I am dying to see Klugs response to this question
oops! 1957 not 1857
[Reply]
Scottw 08:11 PM 08-25-2009
Originally Posted by markem:
oops! 1957 not 1857
Still impressive, they are smoking well? (sorry for the threadjack).
[Reply]
markem 08:16 PM 08-25-2009
Originally Posted by Scottw:
Still impressive, they are smoking well? (sorry for the threadjack).
Amazing. Lots of people here (and CS) have gotten some from me. They can possibly chime in with opinions.
[Reply]
St. Lou Stu 08:19 PM 08-25-2009
I have smoked some 1940's and 50's clear havana sticks that were sublime.
My current oldie is a 70's stick that was gifted to me at Shack.
I plan on breaking it out at next year's Shack.

My current oldie that I have a box of is '97 du Deputes.
As far as NCs go I have some 2003 Anejos... I'll get around to those after my daughter's inaugural soccer season wraps up in October.
[Reply]
ValorBali41 08:41 PM 08-25-2009
ITs amazing that an Aficionado was able to keep a cigar for literally a century. This passion goes way back!


But that is a good thing, as our history becomes that much richer! :-)
[Reply]
qwerty1500 09:15 PM 08-25-2009
Still have a couple of 97 Punch Punch left from a box. Really loved their 23 cousins. Probably smoke one some time and leave the other one tucked away for another 10 years or so.
[Reply]
cherrybomb 09:47 PM 08-25-2009
some 98 punch coronas
[Reply]
dubnick 10:15 PM 08-25-2009
I was gifted some assorted 99 cc's
[Reply]
SkinsFanLarry 10:18 PM 08-25-2009
Some 1996 CAO Maduro's....when they were good and still made in Costa Rico.
[Reply]
DPD6030 10:22 PM 08-25-2009
I have a Blackstone 1950 cigar given to me at my very first herf in Canada by Dave (Old Sailor). One day I plan to smoke it. Now I just look at the very yellow cello and :-)
[Reply]
n3uka 11:01 PM 08-25-2009
2 boxes of german cigars from wwII.

Will have to get the guts to break one open one day. :-)
[Reply]
Don Fernando 02:12 AM 08-26-2009
a spanish joy, guessed production between 1890 and 1910, but for certain older then 1930. I got it from Tanith.
[Reply]
icehog3 02:52 AM 08-26-2009
Have some 50s clear Havanas....but the best old ones I have are from the 70s, just like Bruce's dumps.
[Reply]
NCRadioMan 02:54 AM 08-26-2009
Originally Posted by icehog3:
Have some 50s clear Havanas....but the best old ones I have are from the 70s, just like Bruce's dumps.
:-):-)








Don'tcha just hate posts like this one. :-)
[Reply]
joeybear 05:01 AM 08-26-2009
I have about 5 or 6 Partagas ISOMs from about '95 or '96. They were my dad's and I smoke one a year on his birthday.
[Reply]
68TriShield 05:20 AM 08-26-2009
Originally Posted by DougBushBC:
I agree with Dave. I have a few 99 CCs that were gifted RECENTLY but i have been smoking a lot of late 90s stuff that I have been gifted/traded for because to be honest I love them!
I love most cigars,fresh or aged.
I smoke them because I might not be here tomorrow.Another day is not a given :-)
[Reply]
shilala 06:03 AM 08-26-2009
I have a few from the 40's, 50's, and 60's. I've tried them all.
The oldest I've smoked was an old Betsy Ross. She was almost 100.
There's a review right here.
Scott and I smoked a 40's La Prosa the same day.
[Reply]
Wolfgang 06:07 AM 08-26-2009
1947. It will Die at EYH
[Reply]
Page 2 of 4
< 12 34 >
Up