OK, those of you that have had them all, I want your opinions. I have had 1 each of the #1 & #2, and I'd love to get more of them, but they are no longer available. I had a couple #3s, but they did not impress as much. I have two each of the #4 regular and maduro, but have not touched them yet.

How would you rank all 5 incarnations of this cigar?
Which one was your best? (why)
Which was worst? (why)
They were all close?

I especially want to know where the #5 ranks. I am thinking of picking up a couple, but am hesitant to pay the price for them as I just do not like spending that kind of coin for cigars.

Peace of the Lord be with you.

Todd
[Reply]

Haven't had the first 3 editions, but I'd probably rank the ones I've had 5 > 4oscuro > 4. The 4s would have beat the 4 oscuros if they hadn't completely lost all spice and tons of flavor within 6 months. There wasn't a huge difference between them all to me, at least when fresh.
[Reply]

Wow, I thought there would be more responses to this.

So, are you saying that the Small Batch have been losing flavor after sitting? Have you noticed that with other LG stuff? (Not talking the LFD lines of his)
[Reply]