Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
All Cigar Discussion>Ghurka #9 ???
MUNKY 06:26 PM 12-16-2013
125th Aniversary XO

FACTORY LOCATION: Dominican Republic
WRAPPER: Brazil
BINDER: Ecuador
FILLER: Nicaragua, Brazil, Dom. Rep.
PRICE: $10.99
RING GAUGE: 60
LENGTH: 6"
RATING: 94

Say what? Come on seriously? A 94! This is why I have all but steered away from these type reviews....
[Reply]
icehog3 06:31 PM 12-16-2013
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
[Reply]
the jiggler 06:42 PM 12-16-2013
Originally Posted by icehog3:
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
Not gonna say it....
[Reply]
bruceolee 06:51 PM 12-16-2013
Originally Posted by icehog3:
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
That's what she............can't do it! too lame!
[Reply]
Remo 06:57 PM 12-16-2013
Originally Posted by icehog3:
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
Someone is gonna have a new sig. line thanks to the Admiral :-)
[Reply]
Zane 07:26 PM 12-16-2013
I was surprised as well.
[Reply]
EricF 07:33 PM 12-16-2013
Originally Posted by icehog3:
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
Thanks Admiral!!! :-)
[Reply]
AdamJoshua 07:34 PM 12-16-2013
Probably should have stopped after #3. :-)
[Reply]
RobR1205 07:35 PM 12-16-2013
I actually have one laying around in the humi still in the cellophane...might have to do a review just for your entertainment...
[Reply]
Smoqman 11:13 AM 12-17-2013
Never tried one (actually I've never had a Ghurka of any kind), but will "try" this one. "Ratings" (to me) are just a recommendation - I don't care who makes it, as long as it is hencho de mano, made from quality ingredients, and that care has been taken to ensure it smokes well. If the company has bad business practices, or tells "tales" about how their products are produced, I steer clear of them, otherwise - I'll have a go.....

Everyone's palate is different (at least to some degree) and all palates (taste buds) are ever changing.........
[Reply]
dave 11:16 AM 12-17-2013
Originally Posted by MUNKY:
125th Aniversary XO

FACTORY LOCATION: Dominican Republic
WRAPPER: Brazil
BINDER: Ecuador
FILLER: Nicaragua, Brazil, Dom. Rep.
PRICE: $10.99
RING GAUGE: 60
LENGTH: 6"
RATING: 94

Say what? Come on seriously? A 94! This is why I have all but steered away from these type reviews....
Curious.....What was your impression of this cigar?
[Reply]
MUNKY 12:57 PM 12-17-2013
Didn't make it through 2 inches and tossed it, plus the big ring gauge didn't care for at all. Maybe it's a preconceived notion that all ghurka taste like **** to me, but they do.
[Reply]
Lockspur 01:03 PM 12-17-2013
Originally Posted by MUNKY:
Didn't make it through 2 inches and tossed it, plus the big ring gauge didn't care for at all. Maybe it's a preconceived notion that all ghurka taste like **** to me, but they do.
So, to me, that begs the question: which is better…Ghurka or Victor Sinclair?
[Reply]
czerbe 01:13 PM 12-17-2013
Originally Posted by Lockspur:
So, to me, that begs the question: which is better…Ghurka or Victor Sinclair?


I will not answer this Question!!! :-)
[Reply]
Whipper Snapper 01:24 PM 12-17-2013
Originally Posted by icehog3:
It might taste crummy, but at least it's huge. :-)
I should've known you'd be the first to spy a ghurka thread.
Someone send me one unbanded and I'll smoke it. Just so long as I don't know what it is :-)
[Reply]
Sweet_Leaf_PDX 03:21 PM 12-17-2013
It must have been shipped to them with $100 bills used for the packing material.
[Reply]
Adriftpanda 05:06 PM 12-17-2013
I want to try it now... never know.
[Reply]
Up