cmitch 12:26 AM 06-19-2013
A brother brought this stick to the book club tonite. He smoked one and said he had to put it down. He said it tasted downright nasty, like it had cleaner or something in it. It smells literally like wet grass that molded under a lawnmower deck (anyone who has cleaned a lawnmower deck would know exactly what smell I'm describing). Everyone examined it and smelled it. Just like wet, moldy grass. After some discussion, we all agreed there's no way this cigar will ever be anything but a dissectable specimen to see what the hell is up. Nastiest cigar I've ever smelled. Pic attached.
[Reply]
Robulous78 12:36 AM 06-19-2013
Let us know what you find... thanks for the heads up
[Reply]
'What is a Rolando Reyes cigar with a touch of mold?' ....for $200, Alex
[Reply]
688sonarmen 07:31 AM 06-19-2013
Wow, how things can change. That brand at one time was one of the best.
[Reply]
oooo35980 09:24 AM 06-19-2013
Damn, where did he get the thing? I've seen humidors that smelled like straight up mildew, usually ones at gas stations or grocery stores, maybe it was badly stored?
[Reply]
Lockspur 09:27 AM 06-19-2013
If it tasted like it had "cleaner" in it, then it COULD be too young. I've had a couple that were straight up Windex, but after a few months in storage, they were just fine.
:-)
[Reply]
the nub 10:44 AM 06-19-2013
did it smell like ammonia? If so, it's sick.
[Reply]
cmitch 12:06 PM 06-19-2013
Originally Posted by oooo35980:
Damn, where did he get the thing? I've seen humidors that smelled like straight up mildew, usually ones at gas stations or grocery stores, maybe it was badly stored?
He got it from Neptune, supposedly a highly rated cigar which is what prompted him to purchase the sampler that had these in it. He said it was downright nasty, like smoking a piss soaked cigar.
Originally Posted by the nub:
did it smell like ammonia? If so, it's sick.
It's too sick to recover. We all agreed after examination that the tobacco is basically uncured and is probably molding inside. The ammonia smell will knock you down.
[Reply]
bstarrs 12:15 PM 06-19-2013
Like smoking piss? Definitely sounds like ammonia, that couldn't have made him feel very nice after smoking it...
[Reply]
macsauce13 01:01 PM 06-19-2013
I have several bundles of these and several other Cuba Aliados versions. I really like them and haven't experienced anything like this. Really hate to hear you had a bad experience.
[Reply]
cmitch 06:15 PM 06-19-2013
Originally Posted by macsauce13:
I have several bundles of these and several other Cuba Aliados versions. I really like them and haven't experienced anything like this. Really hate to hear you had a bad experience.
Maybe a bundle of improperly cured tobacco was mistakenly used. Maybe it was improper storage? Who knows?
[Reply]
NCRadioMan 07:11 PM 06-19-2013
I thought that was advertised profile of Cuba Aliados?
:-)
[Reply]
deebomitchell 12:12 AM 06-20-2013
Clayton did you cut it open yet?
[Reply]
cmitch 11:27 AM 06-20-2013
Originally Posted by deebomitchell:
Clayton did you cut it open yet?
I'm waiting on the smell to dissipate. I'm afraid it'll kill my parrot.
[Reply]
cjhalbrooks 11:28 AM 06-20-2013
Originally Posted by cmitch:
I'm waiting on the smell to dissipate. I'm afraid it'll kill my parrot.
It could be used like a bird in a coal mine. If the bird dies GET OUT!!!
:-)
[Reply]
cmitch 11:29 AM 06-20-2013
Originally Posted by cjhalbrooks:
It could be used like a bird in a coal mine. If the bird dies GET OUT!!! :-)
Not going to kill a $1200 bird to check out a $5 cigar.
:-)
[Reply]
cjhalbrooks 11:37 AM 06-20-2013
cmitch 06:59 PM 06-20-2013
Originally Posted by cjhalbrooks:
well fine be that way :-)
Devil bird says, "Kiss it!"
:-)
[Reply]
RobR1205 07:32 PM 06-20-2013