Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Onyx Reserve #4
kingcobradude 10:46 PM 11-15-2011
picked this up at some b&m. priced a lil high there.

Construction: 9/10 a lil tight, but really well made overall

Flavors: 8/10 Started off like a strong black tea, then moved to a nutty leather, then a dark deep earthy flavor

burn: 7/10 a lil uneven, and I had to touch it up a bit.

Ash: 8/10 perfectly white, a couple minor pots. Very solid. stayed on an inch and a half

I would definately buy this again. Ill prolly buy a box soon. I almost got it to the nub, but my feet and hand losing feeling stopped that
[Reply]
deadrise 11:04 PM 11-15-2011
nice review and welcome to the party!!!
[Reply]
3SmokesaRound 11:24 PM 11-15-2011
One of the best budget sticks out there IMO. Love the churchills with some age on the golf course in the morning.
[Reply]
Emjaysmash 04:59 AM 11-16-2011
This cigar made you lose feeling in your hands and feet?!

:-)

Nice Review, I haven't had one of these in a while.
[Reply]
Dunkel 05:25 AM 11-16-2011
It's a decent smoke if you can get one to draw.
[Reply]
Ogre 09:51 AM 11-16-2011
I have one that was gifted. Need to light it up and give it a try.
[Reply]
Blak Smyth 10:15 AM 11-16-2011
Originally Posted by Emjaysmash:
This cigar made you lose feeling in your hands and feet?!

:-)

Nice Review, I haven't had one of these in a while.
Either that or it is cold out!:-)
Thanks for the review I have been passing on these at a B&M but maybe I will give one a shot now.
[Reply]
dave 10:21 AM 11-16-2011
Thanks for the review. Glad you liked it - they can generally be found on the cheap. I've never had much luck with them; super tight draw and a sour finish on the few I've tried.
[Reply]
DaBear 11:01 AM 11-16-2011
Can't go wrong with these as a cheapie. They're great for mornings with a cup of coffee. Also I found them to pair with Guinness pretty well, back when I basically only drank Guinness.
[Reply]
Up