Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Punch Rare Corojo magnum
BlackIrish 08:39 PM 11-27-2008
The cigar: Punch Rare Corojo magnum

Nutritional information
Vitola: 5.25 x 54 square pressed
Origin: Honduras (Cofradia)
Wrapper: Ecuadoran Sumatra
Binder: Connecticut broadleaf
Filler: Dominican Republic, Honduras, Nicaragua

The marketing:

JR: Started as a limited edition brand in 2001, Villazon's master cigar maker, Frank Llaneza, began production of small quanties of these special, square-pressed cigars each year. Still handcrafted with all-Cuban seed black tobaccos, the cigars are wrapped in the richest of the dark Sumatra wrappers grown in the mountains of Ecuador. These square-pressed beauties have a woodsy aroma, spicy flavor, and a smooth draw.

Cigar.com: Punch Rare Corojo is the most popular Punch line extension. Only released once a year, the Rare Corojo is always at the top of the ratings, and the blend keeps getting better year after year. The cigar starts with a red and rough looking Colorado shade wrapper that conceals a complex blend of Dominican and Nicaraguan long fillers. The result is a robust full bodied cigar that is exceptionally full flavored. One of the most notable characteristics of the Rare Corojo is how well it ages. While these cigars are great right out of the box, an additional one to two years of aging takes the Rare Corojo to a whole new level. Many aficionados pick up at least two boxes every year so they can put one aside for long term storage.

General Cigar's CigarWorld:
The History:
When Punch Rare Corojo was introduced in a limited edition some years ago, the taste and aroma of the cigars was so exceptional, all of them were sold very quickly. Then, in the year 2001, Villazon cigar master Frank Llaneza began producing in small quantities, a new square-pressed version of the cigar that is even more robust than the original.

The Cigar:
Punch Rare Corojo cigars are made with extra rich, dark Sumatra wrapper leaves that are grown in the mountains of Ecuador. The filler is a rich blend of Honduran, Nicaraguan and Dominican tobaccos.

The Experience:
If you want a Punch cigar with an extra kick to it, Punch Rare Corojo, in the distinctive red box, is the one for you.



Prelight: Despite the name, these cigars don't have a corojo wrapper (always wondered about this . . .) but a rustic somewhat veiny Sumatra wrapper, a wrapper that looks redder because of the red double band. The foot shows a swirl of different tobaccos. Nicely square pressed, the cigar feels firm. Aroma is tobacco and earth. The cap is a bit bumpy but it slices cleanly and I get a good draw.

Image

Image

Image


Burn: Easy to light, and a decent burn: a bit wavy but no problems and no touchups. The ash is a whitish light gray with some darker gray stripes, firm and not flaky, holding for quite a while before ashing. It produces a good volume of smoke -- always a plus.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Flavor: I got good, full, Honduran flavor from the lighting. Not much pepper, mostly earth, leather, some clove type spice. The flavor stayed pretty consistent throughout the smoke; there's not a lot of transition or dynamics here, although the leather and earth flavors did build a bit in intensity through the last third. The flavor is good, in the medium to medium full range, with a medium body, smooth smoke. It never got hot on my lips. Finish is clean and relatively short.

Nothing wondrous, and relatively undemanding. But that's not to criticize. Like a lot of cigars from Cofradia, this is a solid, flavorful, well-made smoke.
[Reply]
dunng 08:40 PM 11-27-2008
Very nice review Ed! For me this is a solid backup if I cannot find anything at the local B&M... :-)
[Reply]
Da Klugs 10:01 PM 11-27-2008
Nice review. YOu might want to try the Pita if you want a contrast that size makes in the flavors in this line.
[Reply]
BlackIrish 10:10 PM 11-27-2008
Cool! Thanks for the tip.
[Reply]
JimmyPeaches 11:46 PM 06-30-2009
Smoked my first one of these tonight. I'd say it's decent and as you have described, but not really anything to write home about. I bought 3 so maybe if they get some age they might come around.
[Reply]
bobarian 01:51 AM 07-01-2009
Originally Posted by Da Klugs:
Nice review. YOu might want to try the Pita if you want a contrast that size makes in the flavors in this line.
I prefer the Pita's, the Magnum's seem to burn a bit hot even when smoked slowly. The pita has a nice balance of strength and flavor. The Pita's were my very first box purchase!:-)
[Reply]
Smoke Naked 07:49 AM 07-01-2009
Fantastic review and pics, thank you.
[Reply]
e-man67 07:53 AM 07-01-2009
I use to smoke the hell out of these things....went through about 4 boxes....I think they are a very good smoke!
[Reply]
Volt 07:58 AM 07-01-2009
Originally Posted by e-man67:
I use to smoke the hell out of these things....went through about 4 boxes....I think they are a very good smoke!
Now that's what I call an endorsement :-)
[Reply]
kelmac07 09:29 AM 07-01-2009
Great review and pics!!
[Reply]
darkninja67 09:54 AM 07-01-2009
Great review. I have to revisit these soon as I enjoyed them in the past.
[Reply]
AD720 10:53 AM 07-01-2009
Funny I randomly grabbed one of these last night and I really enjoyed it. Nice review!
[Reply]
shilala 11:18 AM 07-01-2009
Nice review, Eddie.
Good little cigar, and I think you nailed the description right on the head. :-)
[Reply]
Mr B 06:33 PM 07-01-2009
Nice review. I would say you described this smoke very well. My thoughts (flavor notes)exactly.
[Reply]
Up