Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
General Discussion>The 50 Best MLB Plays
hotreds 09:07 PM 09-12-2011
Let's argue about something other than women's putative good looks!

http://www.menshealth.com/best-life/...09122011-_-hed
[Reply]
TheTraveler 09:44 PM 09-12-2011
Thank you for that link. :-) I love that stuff. Just read through Cy Young's spot ... a pitcher would have to average 20 wins per season for 25 years to come up 12 shy of his win record. Damn!
[Reply]
kelmac07 10:13 PM 09-12-2011
Did any of my Mets even make the list?
[Reply]
jonumberone 06:04 AM 09-13-2011
This is a pretty awful list!
Too many glaring omissions, and the order is way out of sequence.
Plus the list is painted with too broad a brush.
Not all items on the list are actual plays.

No Joe Carter
No Pete Rose, Ray Fosse
No Piazza Home run after 9/11
No Mantle hitting the ball out of Yankee stadium
In keeping with the style of the list
No Dimaggio 56 game hit streak
No Teddy ballgame hitting .406
No Sosa Macguire HR race in 98

I could post on and on about the order!
[Reply]
Blak Smyth 07:37 AM 09-13-2011
Was glad to see this one!

10. Kirk Gibson's Game-Ending Home Run
[Reply]
kelmac07 08:02 AM 09-13-2011
Originally Posted by kelmac07:
Did any of my Mets even make the list?
Was surprised to see quite a few Mets in the list. :-) Although I gotta gree with Dom...where is Piazza's post 9/11 HR. :-)
[Reply]
Up