Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 2 of 2
< 12
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Puros Indios Reserva Maxima ’03 Robusto
pnoon 01:51 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by SchizoFilly:
.....but why do that when you can shoot from the hip on a zombie thread :-)
Don't need any gasoline on a potential fire. :-)
[Reply]
SchizoFilly 02:02 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by pnoon:
Don't need any gasoline on a potential fire. :-)
aw, come on....this close to the 4th nobody would notice a few extra fireworks:-)
[Reply]
EEE 02:03 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by pnoon:
Don't need any gasoline on a potential fire. :-)
I'm a big boy - I can take. :-)
[Reply]
pnoon 02:03 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by SchizoFilly:
aw, come on....this close to the 4th nobody would notice a few extra fireworks:-)
:-)
The admin team here has enough to do without any additional fireworks.
[Reply]
SchizoFilly 02:09 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by pnoon:
:-)
The admin team here has enough to do without any additional fireworks.
and a great job you do:-)
[Reply]
pnoon 02:10 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by SchizoFilly:
and a great job you do:-)
Thanks. We appreciate the support.
[Reply]
bigloo 03:42 PM 07-07-2009
This could be a good one. EEE, welcome. Once the storm dies down you will enjoy yourself here. I have tried 2-3 different PI blends, none tickled my fancy, one (the plain green label) was outright nasty. That being said, a good blind taste test is always welcome in my books. Make sure you guys get a thread going for all to bookmark.
[Reply]
The Poet 03:54 PM 07-07-2009
Hey, whaddaya know - somebody in hot $#!+, and it ain't me!

Welcome to the Asylum, 3E - enjoy your stay. Here, here's your meds.
[Reply]
Garbandz 04:05 PM 07-07-2009
I would also like to try a blind taster,I love reviewing cigars,and I used to enjoy Aliados as a regular smoke.I have not had any of the newer offerings,I would gladly review some.Thanks for joining us here,and welcome!!!!
[Reply]
Starscream 05:26 PM 07-07-2009
Knocking my review is alright w/ me. Knocking my marriage is not.
I will take you up on your offer though. I may not be able to tell which ones are the PIs, but I will be able to tell you which one's I don't like (and I'll bet that they will be the Indios sticks).
[Reply]
EEE 05:39 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by andysutherland:
Knocking my review is alright w/ me. Knocking my marriage is not.
I will take you up on your offer though. I may not be able to tell which ones are the PIs, but I will be able to tell you which one's I don't like (and I'll bet that they will be the Indios sticks).
I wasn't knocking your marriage - and if it was taken that way I publicly apologize.

I already had one guy step up for the 10 spot and I'll send 10 to you as well. I'm not going to say if they are, or are not, the same cigars as the other gentleman.

Please pm me a mailing addy
[Reply]
mcmoyer 06:59 PM 07-07-2009
Alrighty! I can hardly wait to see the results of the blind smoke test here!! Way to go 3E!!

:-)
[Reply]
ade06 10:52 PM 07-07-2009
Originally Posted by EEE:
I wasn't knocking your marriage - and if it was taken that way I publicly apologize.

I already had one guy step up for the 10 spot and I'll send 10 to you as well. I'm not going to say if they are, or are not, the same cigars as the other gentleman.

Please pm me a mailing addy
Nice recovery. I look forward to reading the two blind reviews.:-)
[Reply]
borndead1 08:32 AM 07-08-2009
Originally Posted by EEE:
I wasn't knocking your marriage - and if it was taken that way I publicly apologize.

I already had one guy step up for the 10 spot and I'll send 10 to you as well. I'm not going to say if they are, or are not, the same cigars as the other gentleman.

Please pm me a mailing addy

Since this was Andy's review, and the challenge was originally issued to him, I can step aside. No problem. :-)
[Reply]
EEE 09:35 AM 07-08-2009
Originally Posted by borndead1:
Since this was Andy's review, and the challenge was originally issued to him, I can step aside. No problem. :-)
the more the merrier - and I have enough cigars right now that I won't miss 20.

It will be interesting to see your guys' reviews side by side.
[Reply]
bigheadmark 09:38 AM 11-16-2009
well....what happened? did the blind test ever occur?
Puros Indios have been hit or miss for me....based on the reserva maxima that I bought off CI several months ago, I will not be buying PI again...I'm of the thought that if you screw me once, IE bad product, then that's it...there are way too many GOOD consistent brands out there to smoke than to give a certain brand a 2nd, or 3rd chance....I give them a shot, and if they fail, then see ya!
[Reply]
Page 2 of 2
< 12
Up