Party Shorts, with about a year and a half/two years' age. (I.e. out of the sick period and back to normal).

Not only do I not get tired of them, when I finish one I have to fight myself not to start up another! :-)
[Reply]

Padron 44th
[Reply]

I'd go with AF Hemi Signature maduro.
Very consistent and tasty cigar.

A close second is PAM and,
third either Ashton VSG or San Cristobal.

subject to change, of course.

Chemyst :-)
[Reply]

Made my short-list, too. :-)
[Reply]

BBF...but I'd have to have enough of them that they could be aged in rotation so I'm never without one that doesn't have a least a year or more on it...
[Reply]

said the same thing a million times before, and it ain't sexy or expensive or impossible to find:

Rocky Patel Sungrown PC - usually smokes these in the factory select bundles, and to me, its what I think of when I want a flat out F*cking CIGAR...this blend tastes like what a cigar should taste like IMO, and the construction/draw has been perfect on every one.
[Reply]

LCG #4 or maybe a Boli CE
[Reply]

psd4 when it is on
[Reply]

Some great cigars being proclaimed here (and some that are new to me).
[Reply]

Partagas Series D #4

Perfect flavor and size
[Reply]

So many great cigars out there..how do you choose just one?

Also..who actually thinks that cigars won't change a bit as time passes?

but if I were to play along I'd like a Festival 2000
[Reply]

Did someone say they wouldn't? Just one more factor to weigh into your choice.
[Reply]