Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Rocky Patel Autumn Collection 2009
macpappy 08:14 PM 10-27-2009
Rockey Patel Autumn Collection 2009 Robusto (5“x50)
Purchased at Habanos in Slidell, La. $6.95
Colorado Maduro Wrapper (Ecuadorian Habano)
Binder & Filler Nicaraguan

I found this to be a Medium bodied cigar with good construction and appearance and an easy but not loose draw. I was intrigued by the pre-light aroma and my first thought was that it reminded me of a Cavendish pipe tobacco. On second thought though I decided that it reminded me of an Illusione 888.
In fact the flavor continued to remind me of the 888 throughout the smoke. It wasn’t what I would called complex but it had a nice clean taste with a mild spiciness and a good finish. I feel it had a nicely balance flavor and sometimes I tasted a light earthiness. sometimes I picked up a hint of untanned leather and in the second half I tasted anise. It started building up in strength in the last third but there was never any bitterness or bite.
This cigar had a nice even burn which was a testament to it good construction. I didn’t have to relit at any point and only did a single touchup in the last third of the smoke. The ash was brown-tinged gray and was fairly straight and held on past the halfway point. It had a very good amount of grayish white smoke.
I didn’t have the opportunity to smoke the Autumn Collection 2008 but I did smoke the most recent Winter, Spring and Summer versions. This one is by far my favorite of the collection.
[Reply]
elderboy02 08:17 PM 10-27-2009
Thanks for the review. I was wondering about these.
[Reply]
RightAJ 08:25 PM 10-27-2009
Heard these were good, I gotta give them a try

aj
[Reply]
timo 08:28 PM 10-27-2009
Nice review
[Reply]
Giant & 49er Fan 10:05 PM 10-27-2009
Thanks for the review. Spring had to be my favorite by Autumn 09 is a close second. :-)
[Reply]
Pilon 11:02 PM 10-27-2009
Nice review. My local B&M just got these in today, can't wait to try it. Local RP Rep came into the shop and handed me a 1961. Didn't even know about it.
[Reply]
klipsch 05:52 AM 10-28-2009
Originally Posted by Pilon:
Nice review. My local B&M just got these in today, can't wait to try it. Local RP Rep came into the shop and handed me a 1961. Didn't even know about it.
I left 10 minutes too soon...
[Reply]
OHRD 06:08 AM 10-28-2009
Thanks for the review! I've got a Spring 09 in my humi, haven't heard much about the Autumn. Good stuff...
[Reply]
macpappy 12:25 PM 10-29-2009
some photos to go with review
Thumbnail 1: prelight
Thumbnail 2: 1/4 in
Thumbnail 3: halfway
Thumbnail 4: where it started burning uneven
Attached: RP_Autumn09_01.jpg (82.1 KB) RP_Autumn09_2.jpg (43.3 KB) RP_Autumn09_4.jpg (44.7 KB) RP_Autumn09_5.jpg (47.6 KB) 
[Reply]
Giant & 49er Fan 12:50 PM 10-29-2009
Originally Posted by Pilon:
Nice review. My local B&M just got these in today, can't wait to try it. Local RP Rep came into the shop and handed me a 1961. Didn't even know about it.
Was it Mark W?
[Reply]
Up