Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>RP Edge Sumatra Toro: Photo Review
DoctaJ 11:01 AM 06-12-2009
Image



Appearance + Pre-Light:
Image
Medium chocolate brown wrapper with a nice oily sheen. There was a small vein running about halfway down the cigar, but other than that was a very smooth cigar. The cigar had a sweet barnyard scent to it and the pre-light draw was perfect with earthy tones.




Location:
Image
My usual smoking location (3rd floor apartment patio) on a some what humid day and overcast skies. There was no breeze at all and better yet, no rain which is a change of pace lately. I paired this cigar with a Sierra Nevada Pale Ale.



1st Quarter:
Image
Starts off pretty mild (which was surprising) with just a subtle sweetness to it. It was soon joined by some subtle earthy tones as well. All in all this stick is starting off somewhat mild but the flavors are tasty.



2nd Quarter:
Image
The same sweet/earthy flavors are there at this section of the cigar, but they are increasing in flavor a little bit. They still are somewhat subtle, but I could tell it was increasing with each puff I took. This part of the cigar was more mild/medium.
[Reply]
DoctaJ 11:01 AM 06-12-2009
3rd Quarter:
Image
At this point of the cigar the sweetness starts to take center stage as the earthy tones start to subside. The sweetness gained some intensity here and I could start to make out the flavors of cherries. This section of the cigar is definitely a solid medium.



4th Quarter:
Image
The cherry sweetness starts to go away and the sweetness becomes more subtle again. However, the earthy flavor has returned and now I can make out some flavors of nuts as well. All the flavors work together to make a pretty flavorful point in this cigar. Again, I would rate this section as a medium.



Conclusions:
I was actually quite surprised that this smoke was more of a medium bodied smoke. I had smoked it's cousin, the maduro, in the past and I remember that being a spice bomb. This stick had a much more subdued flavor to it, with sweetness being the predominant flavor throughout as well as earthy tones and at the end, the flavor of nuts. I wouldn't let the flavor strength fool you though, this baby was STRONG. It definitely lived up to the Edge name in that category. I had a pretty strong nicotine buzz going after finishing this one off. The smoke also had a perfect burn (strong ash throughout), perfect draw and also had billowy white smoke when I exhaled. I am usually more of a full bodied smoker, but I actually liked this cigar. Its flavors weren't in your face and were pretty flavorful. Like I said though, it does pack a punch. I also would say that this is a smoke that, with some age, could become even better. I think this would help make the flavors meld together a little more. I actually have another one from a box pass recently that I will let sit in the humidor for a while to see if this is the case .



Grade:
Appearence - 9.0
Draw/Burn - 10.0
Flavor - 8.0

Final Grade - 8.5
[Reply]
BigAsh 11:08 AM 06-12-2009
mmmmmmm..... RP Edge Sumatra.......Nice review!
[Reply]
dccraft 12:16 PM 06-12-2009
Thanks for the great review. Time to try one of these I believe.
[Reply]
s15driftking 12:39 PM 06-12-2009
that cigar is awesome, good review/
[Reply]
kelmac07 12:44 PM 06-12-2009
Sweet review and great pics.
[Reply]
Ranger_B 01:07 PM 06-12-2009
I love these. I was sorry to see these go.
[Reply]
Ratters 06:35 PM 06-12-2009
One of my favorite smokes. Sadly I'm down to about eight of them. Always burn perfect and taste great. Yeah, more of a medium body smoke but great flavors.
[Reply]
DoctaJ 08:23 PM 06-12-2009
Originally Posted by Ranger_B:
I love these. I was sorry to see these go.
Yeah, what is up with RP ending this wrapper as part of the Edge line :-)
[Reply]
Gonesledn 11:48 PM 06-12-2009
my local has tons of these!

Image
[Reply]
Catfish 11:51 PM 06-12-2009
Originally Posted by Gonesledn:
my local has tons of these!

Image
link to local, please?
[Reply]
DoctaJ 11:58 PM 06-12-2009
Originally Posted by Gonesledn:
my local has tons of these!

Image
:-)
[Reply]
Skywalker 12:49 AM 06-13-2009
OMG!!! What a great cigar!!!

Looks like you smoked the last one left!!!:-)

BTW - I enjoyed see you pairing it with a Sierra Nevada!!!
:-)
[Reply]
m69c44 01:06 AM 06-13-2009
One of my go to gars. Down to my last two
[Reply]
Ranger_B 09:04 AM 06-13-2009
Originally Posted by Gonesledn:
my local has tons of these!

Image
Where is your local? If not maybe we could work something out.
[Reply]
Gonesledn 10:51 AM 06-13-2009
belicosos in orland park illinois

they sell for $5.50 plus tax. they have them in toros and torps.

they have a website, but dont do orders through it, or shipping. ( i have passed their info to someone who tried)

i have no problems picking some up for you guys if you need.
[Reply]
Chris. 11:13 AM 06-13-2009
the edge cigars are good, but they will kick you in the nuts with the Nicotine! Nice review!
[Reply]
GTsetGO 03:11 PM 06-13-2009
great stick. i just can't bring myself to smoke the ones that i have sitting in my humi
[Reply]
Azpostal 03:50 PM 06-13-2009
Thanks for the review and pics.
[Reply]
Gonesledn 07:16 AM 06-14-2009
nice review with pics!


i am going to pick up some for one person that pm'd me, if anyone else would like some, let me know.
[Reply]
Up