Apple 7 28.00%

Poker 9 36.00%

Lovat 8 32.00%

Other 2 8.00%

Straight 7 28.00%

1/4 Bent 14 56.00%

Other Bent 2 8.00%

Smooth 10 40.00%

Rusticated 11 44.00%

Ok, here are the poll choices, if you choose other, please specify in writing in the thread


I picked 3 basic-ish choices for shapes, should be doable, but of course the final say will be whoever ends up wanting to make it for us, and what they're the most comfortable with.

the poll should allow you to pick your preferred combination

we will likely have both a smooth and rusticated available, but I want to get a feel for how many want which

so vote vote vote, let your voice be heard


note: I'm great with a poker or apple, but I'm voting Lovat as I don't have one of those
[Reply]

That's tough. I picked

Smooth
Other: Dublin

I like a partial rustication too, but I enjoy free hands, than again, the apple is a great shape; though I cannot forget about the bulldog. Too many out there...
[Reply]

I voted Poker but whatever is decided is fine with me. :-)
[Reply]

Mike, I think you may have voted Lovat, but I'll put you in the other column (mentally of course)
[Reply]

I voted "other" as I tend to be partial to the Bulldogs. but I will go with whatever :-)
[Reply]

i don't think ppl are voting for all the choices.
looks like you have 3 choices: shape, bend, finish.

6 voted for shape, only 3 voted for both bend and finish.
[Reply]

Oops! I didn't know it was multiple choice.

My corrected vote would be for a Poker smooth finish Straight.
[Reply]

please vote for 1 of each category - shape, bend, finish


thanks!
[Reply]

I voted cause it would be cool to have a CA pipe, but honeslyl, now I have to go look up what apple, poker, lovat mean... :-)
[Reply]

If I did than shwoops.
[Reply]

I voted Poker/straight/rusticated, but Iīm fine with anything else (just donīt like full-bents very much). 1/4 bent poker; lovat, 1/4 apple; canadian; almost anything else would still make me happy.
I donīt really care about rusticated vs. smooth, although the main problem we'll face, I guess, will be to meet the $130 budget, at least with carvers like Senatorov and Zeman. Rusticated pipes could be easier to get by that price.
[Reply]

I voted other shape. I say a volcano shape, 1/4 bent and smooth finish. It would be a very sexy pipe.
[Reply]

I was actually thinking volcano shape myself originally. I don't know how well it would do for a mass production though. It'd be nice though!

WWhermit
:-):
[Reply]

Just in case it comes to this, a lovat can't be a quarter bent. It is one of the few shapes that can't vary by bend, it must be a straight like a Canadian or Lumberman.
[Reply]

I perfer Canadian style pipes,the longer the better.:-)


Prof. Mike:-)
[Reply]

I voted poker, 1/4 bend, rusticated. I need a rusticated to add to the collection.

A volcano would be sweet, but a little spendier methinks.

A long rusticated Canadian would also be cool. I like rusticated Canadians (the more muscular the better....j/k). :-)
[Reply]