Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Benchmade churchill
Don Fernando 08:04 AM 05-13-2010
The Nicaraguan puro Benchmade is made by Don Pepin Garcia with a very consumer friendly price tag. I found boxes of these churchills for less than 70$ at some online cigar shops, which is a steal for these beauties. I got this churchill from a close friend who knew I had never smoked these and that I dig most Pepin made smokes.

Image

This 7x50 Churchill comes packed in cellophane and once released I can smell a mild sour barnyard aroma. The cigar looks good with a nice, dark and oily wrapper that feels silky. The cigar has a tiny pigtail on top. The cigar feels a bit soft, but it is evenly soft so I don't expect construction errors. The predraw is fine and tastes like peppery raisin.

Image

I taste a strong coffee flavor with black pepper. After an inch I also taste a strong wood flavor, the coffee becomes the supporting flavor, the pepper tones down a bit and I also taste some chocolate. These flavors continue to be present, although the coffee fades away until I can't taste it anymore.

Image

Halfway the chocolate gains some strength but that only lasts for about an inch, after that the chocolate is back to the previous weaker strength. At ⅔ the flavors change to toast with chocolate on the background. Near the finish the cigar gets spicy.

Image

Even though this is a 7 inch churchill, the cigar only lasted me 75 minutes, but during that time I got plenty of medium thick smoke. The draw is fine, but the burn was a bit crooked. The ash is dark colored and quite firm. If you would ask me about the strength of the cigar I would tell you that it is definitely full flavored and medium bodied.

Image

Would I buy this cigar again? Yes, I liked it a lot

Appearance: 7 / 10
Construction: 7 / 10
Draw: 7 / 10
Burn: 6 / 10
Smoke & ash: 7 / 10
Aroma first part: 7 / 10
Aroma second part: 7 / 10
Aroma third part: 8 / 10
[Reply]
MedicCook 08:08 AM 05-13-2010
Thanks for the review Ferdie. :-) I have been hit or miss on these.
[Reply]
kelmac07 08:37 AM 05-13-2010
Thanks for the review Ferdie...have not had the pleasure of trying a Benchmade. Will keep my eye out. :-)
[Reply]
Gooner 09:13 AM 05-13-2010
Thanks for the review. Might get some to try out on my next online order.
[Reply]
apNgb 09:25 AM 05-13-2010
wow i can't belive the ash you got on that thing wow. i'd have to agree with ryan, i have had really good ones and some okay ones.
[Reply]
CigarNut 09:30 AM 05-13-2010
Thanks for the review. I always enjoy Pepin cigars and will have to give this one a try.
[Reply]
Up