Pipe Puffer next to the Greenwood Park Mall can hold about 6 people before its standing room only. Indy Cigar Bar is rather inimpressive for cigar selection IMO but they do have a big selection of spirits. Randy's around 38th/Lafayette Square Rd is perhaps the biggest in town for humidor/herf space.
Randy's and Cigar Bar are both an hour round trip, so with the smoking ban in effect, I just converted a portion of my garage into a man cave.
[Reply]
A little West of Randy's is a town called Avon and there is Mister B's Cigar box (I work there
:-)) and on the Northside of Indianapolis there is Cigar Haven to add a couple more.
[Reply]