I need some help pricing cigars... - Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum

I have a big box of cigars sitting here by my desk that I've been trying to get ready for sale and I finally managed to do it.
The problem is that I totally suck at cigar prices. Bad. I have no clue what anything costs, what they're worth, none of that stuff.

What I need is for someone who is really good at that stuff to take a quick look, tell me what they'd cost and what a good, cheap sell price is.
The lots are numbered 1-20, the pics are real good and self-explanatory, and it should only take anyone a few minutes.

If you'll pm me a numbered list in this format...
Lot 1, $50/$35
Lot 2, $75/$55
..it'd be a huge help and I'll hook you up with a fiver of something that's not in there for your trouble.

I don't want to have 20 guys wasting their time, so please post a reply here if you're gonna take a stab at it. I just need one or two lists and I'll average them and make up prices.
And please pm me the results, I don't think that info should be posted here.
It'll be posted on the for sale board as soon as I get time.

Link to the pics.

Thank You!!!
Scott
[Reply]

Send me the list, I could prolly price it out for you by tomorrow nite or fri.
[Reply]

I will give it a shot Scott :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by big_jaygee:
I will give it a shot Scott :-)

I will give somebody else a shot that might be able to do it quicker. a couple things just came up here at work I need to take care of.
[Reply]

Art and Scott (sofaman) are gonna help out, so I'm in good shape, Jason.
Thanks, brother. I very much appreciate your willingness to help!!! :-)
[Reply]

That Padilla Achilles Toro in lot # 19 is a rarity. That was a CI special produced by Pepin just when he was hitting his stride. Ernie and Jose had a falling out (nasty by cigar business standards) and the Achilles came out again by Padilla and it was a Torpedo. Good cigar, but not the same as the original Achilles toro produced by Pepin.
[Reply]

Scott...those two Camachos on the right are the "Face Off". Extremely limited and very rare. Litto made a bet with Christian from Camacho...they both had to create a stick using the others tobacco. This was Litto's offering. :-)

But I 'm certain you already knew this. :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by kelmac07:
Scott...those two Camachos on the right are the "Face Off". Extremely limited and very rare. Litto made a bet with Christian from Camacho...they both had to create a stick using the others tobacco. This was Litto's offering. :-)

But I certain you already knew this. :-)

mellowed out over the years but still a tasty cigar.
[Reply]

Originally Posted by big_jaygee:
mellowed out over the years but still a tasty cigar.

Over the years = 11 years. These are from 2003. :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by kelmac07:
Over the years = 11 years. These are from 2003. :-)

i know how old they are Mac :-)

thanks again Mac

:-)
[Reply]

You've got more cigars than sense, you know that! :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by big_jaygee:
i know how old they are Mac :-)

thanks again Mac :-)

I know that you know Jason. Others unfamiliar with these sticks may not. :-)
[Reply]

Someone, and I can almost remember who, introduced me to the face-offs. I had a couple and immediately sought out a bunch more.
I thought I'd smoked them all until I found those in one of a bunch of bags I stuffed in the bottom of my big humidor.

Whenever my winador gets so full that I start smashing sticks every time I close a drawer, I clean it out, fill up a gallon ziplock, and hide them from myself.
I found tons of really wicked sticks while I've been cleaning out the big humi.
I should probably hit our rare/HTF thread and spread some of that stuff around!!! :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by jjirons69:
You've got more cigars than sense, you know that! :-)

Yes, I do know that. And I still have about a billion more. It's gonna take me five years just to get this down to something manageable, Jamie. Ugh.
[Reply]