I was curious, how much crossover there is in a COMPLETE (best I can do anyway) list.
Basically, there has to be a cigar (or more) that are on more than one list. Where they fall is another story, BUT they made some of the lists.
Could be fun to see the variation and maybe similarities.
M
The two BOLD lists below are the "compiled" best cigars of 2011. The rest is just FYI. Scoring was 25 pts for being first on a list, 24 for second on a list, etc.
Top nine based on "Showings" (showings = represented somewhere on the lists - #. 1-9)
1. Undercrown by Drew Estate - 6
2. E. P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut El Decano - 5
3. Quesada Espana - 5
4. San Lotano Oval - 5
5. Casa Magna Dominus Magnus - 4
6. Quesada Oktoberfest - 4
7. La Casita Criolla - 3
8. Room 101 LTD. Namakubi - 3
9. Tatuaje Black Label - Petit Lancero - 3
Top nine based on the above as I figured you had to be on at least THREE lists to have a good average. List = (name - showings - average score)
1. Tatuaje Black Label - Petit Lancero - 3 - 23
2. Quesada Espana - 5 - 20.6
3. Undercrown by Drew Estate - 6 - 18.67
4. Quesada Oktoberfest - 4 - 18.5
5. La Casita Criolla - 3 - 18.33
6. San Lotano Oval - 5 - 17.4
7. Room 101 LTD. Namakubi - Sucio - 3 - 17.33
8. Casa Magna Dominus Magnus - 4 - 16.25
9. E. P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut El Decano - 5 - 16
StogieReview (Charlie)
1 La Casita Criolla
2 San Lotano Oval by A.J. Fernandez
3 Emilio AF2
4 Casa Magna Domus Magnus Limitada
5 CroMagnon Knuckle Dragger
6 Crowned Heads Four Kicks
7 Undercrown by Drew Estate
8 Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ “Little Robusto”
9 Perdomo Reserve Limited Cameroon Edition Petit Corona
10 EP Carrillo Edición Limitada 2011 “Dark Rituals”
CigarFan
1 La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Magnifico
2 Alec Bradley Prensado Robusto
3 Carlos Toraño Single Region Serie Jalapa Toro
4 JML 1902 Torpedo
5 Los Blancos NINE Toro
6 Padilla Dominus Robusto
7 Undercrown Robusto
8 Carlos Toraño Master BFC
9 Berger and Argenti Clasico Rothschild
10 Alec Bradley Family Blend D3
casafumado
1 Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial Limited Edition 2011
2 Quesada Seleccion Espana
3 Tatuaje La Casita Criolla
4 San Lotano Oval
5 E.P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut
6 Tatuaje Wolfman – Monster Series #4
7 Quesada Oktoberfest
8 Camacho – Room 101 Namakubi
9 Drew Estate Liga Privada Undercrown
10 Casa Miranda by Miami Cigar Co.
havacigar.blogspot
1 Drew Estate Liga Undercrown Robusto
2 Oliva Serie V No. 4
3 AJ Fernandez San Lotano Oval Corona
4 Macanudo Master Series 'Benji' BMM-F3
5 Quesada Espana Short Robusto
6 Drew Estate Liga Privada MF 13 'Pre Release Sample Blend'
7 Cohiba Behike BHK 56 'Laguito No. 6'
8 La Flor Dominicana Colorado Oscuro No. 2
9 Quesada Oktoberfest Bavarian
10 Oliva Studio Tobac Cain FF Toro
11 E.P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut Brillantes
smokingstogie
1 Quesada España Corona
2 Tatuaje NHC Capa Especial
3 E.P. Carrillo Short Run 2010 No.4
4 My Father Le Bijou 1922 Corona Gorda
5 Casa Magna Domus Mangus Limitada
6 Tatuaje Black Label Petite Lancero (Original Release)
7 My Father “El Hijo”
8 Liga Privada Feral Flying Pig
9 Viaje Exclusivo Tower Cigars 45th
10 Padron SI 15th Maduro
SethsHumidor
1 Tatuaje Black Label - Petit Lancero
2 Hoyo de Monterrey - Épicure No.2
3 E.P. Carrillo Core Line Maduro - Club 52
4 Grimalkin by Emilio Cigars - Toro
5 Illusione Epernay - Le Matin
6 Ramon Allones - Gigantes
7 Casa Fernandez Miami - Reserva
8 Rocky Patel 50 - Robusto
9 La Palina El Diario - Gordo
10 Cohiba - Robusto
11 Fuente Fuente Opus X The Lost City - Double Robusto
12 Illusione Cruzado - Domenicos Extra
13 E.P. Carrillo Edición Limitada 2011 (Dark Rituals)
14 Guillermo Leon - Corona Gorda
15 H. Upmann - Sir Winston
16 Punch - Double Corona
17 Tatuaje Fausto - FT127
18 Padrón 1926 Serie - 80th Anniversary Maduro
19 Room 101 LTD. Namakubi - Sucio
20 My Father - No. 1
21 San Lotano Oval - Robusto
22 262 Cigars Paradigm - Torpedo
23 E.P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut - Gran Via
24 PDR 1878 Reserva Dominicana Capa Habana - Robusto
25 Quesada Oktoberfest - The Bavarian
CigarInspector
1 Viaje Exclusivo Tower 45th
2 Illusione MK Ultra
3 Tatuaje Black Petite Lancero (Original Release)
4 Quesada Espana
5 La Flor Dominicana Colorado Oscuro
6 Tatuaje 109 Federal 90th Rosado
7 Tatuaje Wolfman
8 Grimalkin by Emilio Cigars
9 Padron 1964 Anniversary SI-15 Maduro
10 Tatuaje Verite 2009
11 Undercrown by Drew Estate
tinytimblog.blogspot
1 Ashton ESV Spellbound
2 E. P. Carrillo Elenco Series Elites
3 Padron Family Reserve no. 45 natural toro
4 Illusione mj12
5 Fuente Opus X D'Chateau
6 Monte Pascoal Minutos
7 Perdomo Exhibicion Sun Grown Robusto
8 Fuente Opus X Double Corona
9 Arturo Fuente Anejo Reserva no. 48
10 Litto Gomez Diez Americano 2009
11 E. P. Carrillo New Wave Connecticut El Decano
thegentsplace
1 Rocky Patel Puro Cubano
2 5 Vegas Triple-A
3 Don Pepin Garcia Cuban Classic
4 5 Vegas Cask-Strength II
5 5 Vegas Cask-Strength II
6 601 Blue Box-Pressed Maduro
7 Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Gordo Maduro
8 Don Pepin Series JJ
9 Casa Magna Colorado Gran Toro
10 Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 Silver
tomscigars
1 Casa Magna Domus Magnus
2 Quesada Oktoberfest
3 Tatuaje Anarchy
acigarsmoker
1 La Casita Criolla
2 Four Kicks
3 Casa Miranda
4 San Lotano Oval
5 Litto Gomez Small Batch #4
6 Illusione 88 Candela
7 Fausto
8 Undercrown by Drew Estate
9 Emilio AF 1
10 Jamie Garcia Limited Edition 2011
11 Casa Magna Dominus Magnus
12 EP Carrillo New Wave Connecticut
13 Room 101 Namakubi
14 Quesada Espana
15 Cro-Magnon
[Reply]