Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Page 211 of 211
« First < 111161201209210211
Wine, Beer, and Spirits>The Bourbon Thread!!
Porch Dweller 03:13 PM Today
Originally Posted by stearns:
Give me some JD BP Rye any day and thrice on Sundays and I'll be happy. No idea how they manage to make rye that good :-)
I haven't tried it yet. I passed on a bottle a few months back and of course that's the last time I've seen it.
[Reply]
Mikepd 09:21 PM Today
Originally Posted by icehog3:
I wonder if I had a bad sample, Ben, or I'm just not much of a rye guy anymore, but the one I tried did nada for me. I guess I need to give one another shot.
That bottle I brought to Shack in 2023 was meh at best, and as Tom said, he thought it was not a good product. I've tried a few since different pours since from different barrels and I thought they ranged from alright to good, but it hasn't been too high on my list to pick up a bottle. Guess I should give it a try again.

Ben, which would you pick, JD SiB BP Rye (125+ proof) or Michters Barrel Strength Rye (107-115 proof)?
[Reply]
Page 211 of 211
« First < 111161201209210211
Up