x3
[Reply]

Don't laugh,,, Black and Mild............

Jerry in Minnesota.
[Reply]

+1

A great stick for the price.
[Reply]

Private Stock or AF 858.
[Reply]

Padron Londres, so good for the money!
[Reply]

JLPs on the golf course.
[Reply]

Diesel Unlimited Maduro d.x belicoso. A great first cigar of the day.
[Reply]

Smoking it right now, Ramon Bueso Genesis Habano Torpedo.

It's an incredible smoke for just over $2 a stick by the box from the evil auction site.

J. Fuego Sangre del Toro Toro is also very good for about the same money.
[Reply]

Forgot this one... Nica Libre. :-)
[Reply]

Few might think of it as an economy cigar, but if your price point is $5, I'd beg you for the flexibility to throw two more dimes at the question and get a box (or three) of these:
http://smallbatchcigar.com/arturofue...f25-p-275.html
[Reply]

Hand rolled short robusto from the Connecticut Cigar Company.
[Reply]

Also, I will add the Por Larranaga Pantelas. Very cheap and very decent.
[Reply]

CI Legends-Oliva, just got a box for 70 bucks,
[Reply]

Illusione Rothschilds
La Aroma de Cuba Coronas
[Reply]

H. Upmann Half Corona
JL Selction # 2
HdM Epi #2
[Reply]

I think this thread for the most part differentiates itself from the "cheap smoke" thread where the list is inundated with obvious 'cheap' cigars. While I wouldn't want to say there's a distinct line between inexpensive and cheap it isn't so obscure. Hopefully it stays course.

The Guayacan Gallo Pinto is serving me well. Luckily I found them on Serious which knocks the price per stick down to $2.change.

I've wondered about those Legends. How do they feel density wise. House cigars always seem to be under-filled, loose and light.
[Reply]