Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum Mobile
Island (The other ones) Reviews>Nica Libre Potencia Churchill Extra
kaelaria 10:02 PM 05-20-2011
Image


This 7×52 cigar sports an oily velvet dark brown sungrown wrapper with a slight red hue, triple cap, minimal veins, smooth tight seams and rich sweet earth aroma. First light reveals a very snug draw producing minimal smoke with medium bodied flavors of a smooth sweet earth much like it’s aroma. The first third shows much the same, only adding a bit of pepper to the draw flavors. It has a good bit of strength to it but certainly no full body as it’s marketed. The finish is long but subtle without and pepper or spice. 45 minutes in at the 1/2 way point flavors remained unchanged. Just over 1 hour in flavors finally shift a bit but require a double puff to really bring them out. They have transitioned to a soft creamy nuttiness followed by a soft oily earth. 1:-)5 minutes in after two touch-ups and a re-light the cigar is unfortunately out once again and I don’t care to try and continue it. Clearly this one just had severe construction issues. Video on the site
[Reply]
Patrick B 10:10 PM 05-20-2011
I smoked a few of the double robustos and I really think it's the same blend as the Oliva V...
[Reply]
kelmac07 09:14 AM 05-21-2011
Originally Posted by Patrick B:
I smoked a few of the double robustos and I really think it's the same blend as the Oliva V...
I had had a few of the belicosos and was thinking the same thing.
[Reply]
jonumberone 09:44 AM 05-21-2011
Originally Posted by kelmac07:
I had had a few of the belicosos and was thinking the same thing.
I believe your quote was

"Half the price of the V and half the flavor" :-)
[Reply]
kelmac07 09:53 AM 05-21-2011
Originally Posted by jonumberone:
I believe your quote was

"Half the price of the V and half the flavor" :-)
It's like something is missing...the front end lights up just like a V....then the flavor just went away. :-)
[Reply]
kaelaria 10:19 AM 05-22-2011
These are definitely not Vs.
[Reply]
Patrick B 01:29 PM 05-22-2011
Originally Posted by kaelaria:
These are definitely not Vs.
You have definitive proof? Not questioning your position, just interested in what you know. :-)
[Reply]
kaelaria 02:54 PM 05-22-2011
Proof? Seriously?

I have smoked both. They are not the same. Pretty simple.
[Reply]
kaelaria 03:05 PM 05-22-2011
The V's smoke and look very differently with MANY more flavors. http://cigarobsession.com/cigar-revi...-cigar-review/
[Reply]
Patrick B 10:45 PM 05-22-2011
Wow, hostility.

Just wondered if you had official word. I've smoked both and thought they were quite similar.
[Reply]
cobra03 10:53 PM 05-22-2011
It is interesting to note that they also have identical sizes(minus the lancero and figurado) as the V's.
[Reply]
mfarre03 11:43 PM 05-22-2011
Thats too bad, I recently started smoking the V's and absolutely LOVE them. I guess I will have to stick with them and forget the Nica.
[Reply]
Patrick B 12:26 AM 05-23-2011
Originally Posted by mfarre03:
Thats too bad, I recently started smoking the V's and absolutely LOVE them. I guess I will have to stick with them and forget the Nica.
Based on what? Have you tried both?
[Reply]
kaelaria 01:54 PM 05-24-2011
Not hostility just a reaction to a smart comment.

'Same' is not 'similar' If anything is different, they are NOT the 'same'. That's a pretty simple concept. They have obvious differences such as most prominently - the WRAPPER. They are NOT the 'same'. Sure you may taste them as similar IYO, I'm sure there are many that qualify as similar.
[Reply]
thecatch83 02:16 PM 05-24-2011
It's a cigar review, not life or death.....watch/read it and move on! Thanks for sharing Bryan!
[Reply]
mfarre03 02:53 PM 05-24-2011
Have these in the humi, still waiting till they are done..lol
[Reply]
Up